Skip to main

Impact case study database

The impact case study database allows you to browse and search for impact case studies submitted to the REF 2021. Use the search and filters below to find the impact case studies you are looking for.

Search and filter

Filter by

  • University of Central Lancashire
   None selected
  • 24 - Sport and Exercise Sciences, Leisure and Tourism
   None selected
   None selected
   None selected
   None selected
   None selected
   None selected
Waiting for server
Download currently selected sections for currently selected case studies (spreadsheet) (generating)
Download currently selected case study PDFs (zip) (generating)
Download tags for the currently selected case studies (spreadsheet) (generating)
Currently displaying text from case study section
Showing impact case studies 1 to 4 of 4
Submitting institution
University of Central Lancashire
Unit of assessment
24 - Sport and Exercise Sciences, Leisure and Tourism
Summary impact type
Societal
Is this case study continued from a case study submitted in 2014?
No

1. Summary of the impact

‘Football and War’ has achieved impact through collaborations within museums, libraries and related institutions, within schools and in the media. By challenging the myths of the ‘Christmas Truce’ story and bringing the history of football in World War One (WW1) to life in children’s plays and commemorative football matches. Through access to and education about iconic artwork, supporting documentaries and public debates our work has provided powerful lessons of how people can triumph in the midst of a conflict. The resonance from this work lives on through the ‘Football Remembers’ project. Through the dialogue between young people and veterans, commemorative activities, memorial artwork and important educational tools around sport, gender and politics.

2. Underpinning research

Research at the University of Central Lancashire focusing on the cultural and historical aspects of association football has been conducted since the late 1990s. Since 2001 the university has collaborated with the National Football Museum (NFM), then based at Preston North End’s Deepdale Stadium. The International Football Institute (IFI) was established in 2003 as a partnership between the University of Central Lancashire and the NFM. The National Football Museum states that: “The International Football Institute seeks to advance research on all aspects of football, and to make this research available to the widest possible audience, nationally and internationally.”

Within the IFI, Hughson, Adams and Melling’s research challenges existing knowledge on the role of football in relation to war, particularly the mythological constructions that allow football to be used in an ideological way in connection with war. For example, Adams research into the well-known 'Christmas Truce' story [4, 5, 6] finds that football did not effectively provide a means of battlefield détente, as is widely assumed to be the case. Rather than being a source for maintaining a patriotic spirit on the Front, football, more routinely, was found to have provided a recreational means for soldiers to have some exercise and take their minds off the dangers and horrors they experienced and witnessed. Similarly, Adam’s and Hughson’s research into the painting Gassed [3] found that the artist John Singer Sargent, by depicting a football match in the background, was representing in paint what he observed occurring as leisure time on the Front, rather than making a moral statement about the symbiosis of war and football. While the painter C. R. W. Nevinson was making a critical commentary about football averting the attention of the citizenry from an impending Second World War, Hughson’s research shows that Nevinson’s painting Any Wintry Afternoon in England [2] has been more generally received as a depiction of the cultural significance of football to quotidian life in industrial and urban communities.

Melling’s research on the Dick Kerr Ladies football team [1] is largely concerned with dispelling the view that women players were passive social actors who accepted terms for playing football that were served up to them. While circumstances, obviously enough, were significant to what could be done, the women were dynamic actors who, while playing their part in the war effort, used the time to engage in a form of organised sporting activity from which they had previously been excluded. As in the case of the male participants studied in the research of Adams and Hughson, Melling’s research on women players shows how the human enthusiasm to enjoy football has prevailed under the extremely difficult circumstance of both battlefield and war occurring as a backdrop to life.

3. References to the research

  1. Melling, A. (2001) Managing the Munitionettes: The Role of Corporate Paternalism during the Development of Ladies’ Football 1916 – 1921. pp. 119–140, in F. J Capistegui & John K. Walton (Eds) Guerras danzadas. Fútbol e identidades locales y regionales en Europa (Pamplona: EUNSA, Ediciones Universidad de Navarra)

  2. Hughson, J. (2011) ‘Not just Any Wintry Afternoon in England: the curious contribution of C.R.W. Nevinson to ‘football art’, The International Journal of the History of Sport 28 (18): 2670-2687. DOI. 10.1080/09523367.2011.611929

  3. Adams, I. and Hughson, J. (2013) ‘“The first ever *anti-*football painting”? A consideration of the soccer match in John Singer Sargent’s Gassed’, Soccer & Society 14 (4): 502-514. DOI. https://doi.org/10.1080/14660970.2013.810433

  4. Adams, I. (2012) ‘Over the Top: It’s a Blurry Foul’, The International Journal of the History of Sport, 29 (6): 813-831. DOI. 10.1080/09523367.2011.642552

  5. Adams, I. (2015) ‘A Game for Christmas? The Argylls, Saxons, and Football on the Western Front, December 1914’, The International Journal of the History of Sport, 32 (11-12):1395-1415. DOI. 10.1080/09523367.2015.1082084

  6. Adams, I. (2015) ‘Football: a counterpoint to the procession of pain on the Western Front, 1914-1918?’ Soccer & Society 16 (2-3): 217-231. DOI. 10.1080/14660970.2014.961377

All publications are peer-reviewed.

4. Details of the impact

A key driver of the impact has been the relationship between the University of Central Lancashire’s International Football Institute and the National Football Museum (NFM) [A]. This applies especially to the impact related activities of Adams and Hughson. Dr Adams’s main direct impact activity in connection with the National Football Museum was in a consultancy capacity to the major exhibition The Greater Game: Football & the First World War (19 December 2014 – 13 September 2015) [B]. In this capacity, Adams consulted on potential artefacts and delivered a workshop to the staff before the NFM major exhibition. Several of the exhibition cases carried quotes and information attributed to Adams and a quote from him was writ large on the wall above the section dedicated to the Christmas Truces. He was individually mentioned on the acknowledgements board at the exit of the exhibition. His research was used to inform the publication, The Greater Game: A History of Football in World War I (Oxford, Shire Publications, 2014), which accompanied the exhibition. Furthermore, Adams wrote a play, titled A Game for Christmas, which has been used as a teaching resource in primary schools at no cost. The play was made available to schools via Learning and Resources pages of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission website and the resources website of the National Children's Football Alliance (NCFA) [C]. It was also performed, several times, at the National Football Museum during The Greater Game: Football & the First World War exhibition. The play was also performed in a radio version during the two-week ‘Celebrate Sport’ event, which was held by the BBC at Media City UK. This radio version of A Game for Christmas was recorded and disseminated to schools. HRH The Duke of Cambridge, a supporter of the project, remarked:

“We all grew up with the story of soldiers from both sides putting down their arms on Christmas Day, and it remains wholly relevant today as a message of hope over adversity, even in the bleakest of times.” [C]

Adams’s research [3-6] has also been used in other broadcast and print media, public talks and events, to disseminate knowledge to the general public and specialist audiences in promoting discussion and debate about football during WWI. Broadcast media include BBC World Service (global listenership of 150 million per week) Sportshour programme and podcast [D], BBC Radio Lancashire’s Drive Time, BBC Radio 5 Live’s The Daily Interview, and Radio Hochstift in Sennelager, Germany. Adams’s research has been cited in numerous British national and local newspapers as well as the international media (e.g. The Times, The Independent, The Telegraph and The Daily Mail, The Warrington Guardian). A number of public and specialist talks have been delivered including five at the National Football Museum. Adams gave two public talks at The National Archives, Kew (available by podcast) [E, F] and presented a paper at the Ministry of Information Press Centre in Belgrade, Serbia. On 9 December 2014, Adams delivered the ‘Daily Briefing’ to the officers of the 20th Armoured Infantry Brigade at Sennelager before the playing of a commemorative football game. In other school related activities, Adams conducted workshops and gave presentations at several local schools, including Cheetham Primary School, Manchester (19 November 2014) and John Cross Primary School, Bilsborrow (24 February 2015).

Adams was invited to appear at the BBC World War One: The Home Front roadshow at Blackpool and Blackburn on the 21 and 24 June 2014. The BBC estimated the audiences across the two days at approximately 3,000 people. Adams was a contributing consultant historian to the British Library on the WWI pan-European ‘Europeana 1914-1918’ project. He was also a contributing historian on the British Council/Premier League/FA ‘Football Remembers’ project [G]. In relation to this project, an education pack was developed and distributed to 30,000 British schools and mass participation events were organised by the British Embassy network around the world. Adams consulted on the staging of a centennial commemorative football game between British and German army units at Sennelager, Germany in December 2014. The game was attended by thousands of soldiers from both armies and several thousand civilians. Each spectator was given a souvenir programme, which included a page overview authored by Adams about how and why football was played in ‘no man’s land’ on the Front during Christmas of 1914. This page was provided in both English and German.

The Football Association (The FA) invited sculptor Andrew Edwards to create a monument to mark the occasion [H]. Edwards approached the National Football Museum for information about the football played on the Front by the troops in 1914 and Adams was, in turn, invited to consult Edwards on preparation of the art item. A full size bronze was unveiled on 22 December 2015 in Messines Town Square, Belgium on a site identified by Adams as in close proximity to a possible game of football between the 6/Cheshires and their German opponents as briefly described in Lt. Brockbank’s diary exhibited at The Greater Game: Football & the First World War. A modified resin full-size statue was displayed at St Luke’s (“The Bombed-Out Church”) in Liverpool from December 14 to 21, 2014 and then at the Christmas Carol Concert at the Anglican Cathedral in Liverpool. Internationally, the resin statue was also displayed on the site of the former truce in no man’s land in Belgium on Christmas Day 2014, and the following day at the Menin Gate Memorial in Ypres, Belgium [I]. It was also shown at several football grounds to raise awareness and funds for a permanent memorial. The ‘Football Remembers’ project has impacted WW1 veteran football players and young academy footballers through the veterans sharing their experiences of the war and football during the war [G].

As Director of the International Football Institute, Professor Hughson has worked closely with the National Football Museum to ensure the museums interpretations are accessible and appealing whilst being informed by high level curatorial scholarship and expertise [J]. Hughson drew on his published research [2] on the painting Any Wintry Afternoon in England by the British artist C.R.W. Nevinson to advise the National Football Museum to seek a loan of the artwork from its owning institution, the Manchester City Art Gallery. Accordingly, Hughson was involved in discussions regarding the loan with senior staff at both the National Football Museum and the Manchester City Art Gallery. The loan went ahead, and the painting was displayed at the National Football Museum, with key object status, from October 2013 to October 2014. While the painting was on display at the National Football Museum, Hughson gave a number of presentations to the public and provided expert commentary in an educational video made in situ at the National Football Museum in front of the painting. This video was made available as an educational resource to schools. Hughson’s discussion addressed the ‘football and war’ theme regarding Nevinson’s intention in the painting and in regard to subsequent interpretations of the artwork.

Melling's research from the 1990s to the present day on the Dick, Kerr Ladies [1] football team informed the 2017 Channel 4 television documentary, ‘When Football Banned Women’, presented by broadcaster Clare Balding [K, L]. By collaborating with the acclaimed and award-winning Lambert Productions, Channel 4, Jean Williams, Gail Newsham, and Clare Balding CBE, Professor Melling was able to bring the debate over the 1921 FA ban on women’s football into the wider public domain. ‘When Football Banned Women’ received 500,000 ‘hits’ on the first night of screening, and many more via playback, social media, and the national press. Balding noted, during her narration of the documentary, that many of the young women players today had no concept of the game’s history or the struggles their predecessors experienced. This media collaboration therefore acts not only as a vehicle of information, but also as an important tool of informal education around sport, gender and politics. Furthermore, the documentary utilises Melling’s research in understanding the political connotations associated with the FA’s ban on women’s football, highlighting the change of women’s football from fundraising for charities to supporting war-wounded families to focusing on supporting the striking miners. Women’s football and sport journalist, Suzanne Wrack highlights that “With the war over, their fundraising turned to support for workers in struggle, and in particular for the striking miners. “You had women playing football and striking miners, and huge crowds watching them. The whole thing was revolutionary,” says Dr Melling” [M]. Wrack describes the documentary as “Inspiring, moving and analytical.” [M] In May 2019, the British Library hosted a screening of the documentary, followed by a public debate chaired by Clare Balding [L].

Submitting institution
University of Central Lancashire
Unit of assessment
24 - Sport and Exercise Sciences, Leisure and Tourism
Summary impact type
Health
Is this case study continued from a case study submitted in 2014?
No

1. Summary of the impact

Our work has developed an algorithm which identifies clinical subgroups in patients with patellofemoral pain and shown that targeted interventions using these subgroups improves patient outcomes. Our work on non-surgical treatments for knee pain has helped over 50,000 patients per year across Southeast Asia and changed prescription guidelines in New Zealand. In addition, our work has provided evidence to support the use of Orthotic Walkers which have been shown to provide a more effective treatment for the management of ankle injuries. Our work was used as evidence which changed the Korean insurance reimbursement system’s status of Walkers in 2017, helping approximately 20,000 patients per year in South Korea.

2. Underpinning research

Our work on patellofemoral pain was the first to determine the biomechanical effects on the three-dimensional movement and control of the knee when using taping and proprioceptive bracing [1] and demonstrated that improvements in knee control are possible. In addition, our work was the first to identify differences in knee stability in patients with patellofemoral pain when compared with healthy individuals. This helped to establish that patients with patellofemoral pain whom demonstrate deficits in knee stability may be treated using such interventions. Our work provided a “proof of principle”, which explored the improvements in control and mapped these improvements to pain and function and showed their effectiveness during rehabilitation [2]. This work contributed to the consensus statements of the International Patellofemoral Pain Research Retreats (2010-2018) and led to the subsequent hosting of this event at University of Central Lancashire and Manchester University in 2016.

The Targeted Interventions for Patellofemoral Pain Studies (TIPPs) group, funded by Arthritis Research UK (ARUK), was established in 2009 and included colleagues from 11 Universities across four countries. This group, led by staff from University of Central Lancashire, explored the existence of clinical sub-groups in people with patellofemoral pain and successfully identified three sub-groups: a weak and tight muscle group, a weak and over-pronated group, and a previously unidentified strong group (figure 1). This work resulted in an algorithm being developed at the University of Central Lancashire using hierarchical clustering techniques, which allowed the allocation of patients to their respective subgroups [3]. The TIPPs algorithm was used to confirm the presence of similar sub-groups in the wider population and showed clinically important benefits when using targeted interventions for each subgroup compared to a multimodal treatment consisting of a combination of all components of the treatments within all three targeted interventions [2].

Embedded image

Figure 1 - Three clinical sub-groups of people with patellofemoral pain

A collaboration between Manchester Metropolitan University, University of Central Lancashire and Edge Hill University secured further funding from ARUK (2016) and Versus Arthritis (2019) to develop a mobile app (Appatella). Appatella was released on Google Play in 2018 [A], incorporating the algorithm, allowing dissemination to clinicians and implementation into clinical practice. This enabled clinicians to sub-group these patients within the clinical setting for the first time, which is being used by key opinion leaders to guide patients through targeted rehabilitation programmes in Southeast Asia [B].

Embedded image Much of our work aims to provide clinicians with evidence about treatments to assist patient recovery after injury. This has included the efficacy of knee bracing in Patellofemoral Pain, Anterior Cruciate Ligament injuries and knee Osteoarthritis [1, 2, 4, 5]. However, another example of our work is the testing and development of Orthotic Walkers [6] (Figure 2), which are used in the management of ankle fractures and Achilles tendon ruptures and have been shown to provide a faster and more effective recovery than immobilisation casting techniques. Our work was the first paper to report the biomechanical effects on the movement and loads on the knee and hip joints when wearing these devices. This work considered the design of the footplate and angle of inclination of the shank in different Orthotic Walkers and determined that different designs showed different loads and gait patterns. This is an important factor, as the correct load is required to optimise the healing process, and we were subsequently asked to input in the design and testing of the next generation of Orthotic Walkers for DJO inc.

Figure 2 Orthotic Walker

3. References to the research

  1. Selfe J, Thewlis D, Hill S, Whitaker J, Sutton C, Richards J, (2011) A Clinical Study of the Biomechanics of Step Descent Using Different Treatment Modalities for Patellofemoral Pain. Gait & Posture. 34; 92-96.

  2. Yosmaoglu, HB, Selfe J, Sonmezer E, Sahin IE, Duygu SC, Ozkoslu MA, Richards J, Janssen J (2020). Targeted Treatment Protocol in Patellofemoral Pain: Does Treatment Designed According to Subgroups Improve Clinical Outcomes in Patients Unresponsive to Multimodal Treatment? Sports Health. 12(2):170-180 DOI:10.1177/1941738119883272

  3. Selfe J, Dey P, Callaghan M, Witvrouw E, Richards J, Sutton C, Stokes M, Martin D, Dixon J, Hogarth R, Baltzopoulos V, Ritchie E, Arden N, Turner D, Janssen. J. (2016) Are there three main subgroups within the patellofemoral pain population? A detailed characterisation study of 127 patients to help develop targeted Intervention (TIPPs). British Journal of Sports Medicine. DOI:10.1136/bjsports-2015-094792

  4. Hanzlíková I, Richards J, Hébert-Losier K, Smékal D (2019). The effect of proprioceptive knee bracing on knee stability after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Gait & posture 67, 242-247

  5. Jones RK, Nester CJ, Richards JD, Kim WY, Johnson DS, Jari S, Laxton P, Tyson SF (2013). A comparison of the biomechanical effects of valgus knee braces and lateral wedged insoles in patients with knee osteoarthritis, Gait & Posture. 37; 3:368-372. DOI: 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2012.08.002

  6. Richards J, Payne K, Myatt D, Chohan A (2016). Do orthotic walkers affect knee and hip function during gait? Prosthetics and Orthotics International 40;137-141

all articles cited are from peer reviewed journals

All outputs can be supplied by the HEI on request

4. Details of the impact

The annual prevalence of patellofemoral pain (PFP) in the general population is estimated to be around 23%. No standardised treatment for PFP exists, therefore physiotherapy treatment varies widely and comprises of a mixed package, or multimodal approach, which is delivered on a trial-and-error basis and leads to poor outcomes, with 90% of people reporting pain for at least four years following diagnosis. Our work demonstrates a paradigm shift by identifying specific patient sub-groups using six low cost, quick and simple clinical assessments requiring minimal equipment. This allows clinicians to identify subgroups and therefore provide targeted interventions for specific presentations, with the goal of improving patient outcomes in those unresponsive to treatment.

In order to implement the subgrouping, the app “Appatella” was developed [A]. This offers a direct link with our subgrouping algorithm without the need for complex calculations and incorporates instructions on how to perform the clinical assessments without the need for additional training. Appatella is a GDPR compliant, digital clinical tool available in both Android and Apple iOS formats, which consists of three main components. Firstly, a clinician interface, which allows subgrouping to guide treatment decision-making through the algorithm. Secondly, a clinician/patient interface which delivers clinical interventions, including outcome measures and reminders. Finally, a web-based database tool for clinicians and researchers that allows the creation and storage of clinical interventions with outcome measures. This uses a variety of media which can be deployed and implemented through the mobile app. The feedback received to date shows that clinicians recognise the subgroups and strongly support the need to develop a quick and simple system to allocate patients to these subgroups [B, C]. Since 2018 the beta version of Appatella has been downloaded by over 1,000 clinicians across 30 countries and is due to be released fully in late 2020. This will facilitate the assessment and subgrouping as well as the delivery of targeted treatments for this problematic condition.

In 2015 we presented the concept of a “ladder of intervention” for musculoskeletal knee problems at the World Confederation for Physical Therapy. This led to the development of the concept of assessing four key factors: Pain, Alignment, Strength and Stability (PASS). Our work has shown there are a number of interventions that can have a positive effect on all these factors. These include functional and proprioceptive knee bracing which we have demonstrated can help patients with Patellofemoral Pain, Anterior Cruciate Ligament injuries and knee Osteoarthritis [1,2,4,5]. The PASS concept has gained considerable clinical and commercial interest and has been incorporated into the marketing strategy for DJO inc., one of the largest providers of medical devices and services in the world [D]. We have had a significant impact on practitioners through over 200 invited talks to clinical groups, sports clubs, companies and academic groups in over 30 different countries across six continents since 2013, and a series of YouTube videos which have been viewed over 15,000 times [E]. This has had a positive effect on the prescription of knee bracing; for example, a seminar tour by Professor Richards in New Zealand in 2018 resulted in a 23% increase in knee brace sales, indicating a change in clinical practice with an increase in the prescription of knee bracing, this was directly attributed to the presentation of our research findings and was described as “a direct and measurable positive impact on our business” by the New Zealand sales manager for DJO Global [F]. This has subsequently produced a “noticeable shift of treatment in the rehabilitation space towards the use of functional bracing to aid in the improvement of movement patterns, reduce pain and immobility secondary to fear avoidance” which has led to changes in New Zealand’s Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) policy, which now funds the prescription of lower limb bracing through physiotherapy and podiatry [F]. This is a significant development that emphasises the acceptance of bracing as an important part of the rehabilitation process and a way to get people back to work in less time than without bracing. Furthermore, seminars by Richards across the Asia Pacific region between 2014-2020, which considered the prescription of bracing for knee instability, has influenced the management of over 50,000 patients across Southeast Asia and has been directly attributed to our work [B, C, D, G]. Additionally, in South Africa in 2019, Richards ran a similar seminar series. In a survey of approximately 300 delegates, 88% indicated they would be likely or very likely to change their clinical practice as a result of what they had learned.

Up until 2017, South Korea has used Plaster of Paris casting for treating ankle fractures. In 2017, our work on Orthotic Walkers was submitted as evidence along with nine other papers to the National Health Insurance system in South Korea to promote the use of Orthotic Walkers over traditional treatment methods [D, I]. As a result, these devices were approved for use in clinical practice which included financial reimbursement. Estimates based on sales indicate that around 20,000 patients per year, who would have been treated using Plaster of Paris casting, are now been treated using Orthotic Walkers, which have been shown to provide a faster and more effective recovery [I]. In addition, our work features strongly in the marketing materials from DJO Inc., which has been used as marketing evidence on the efficacy of these devices [I]. DJO Inc. sell millions of these devices each year globally. These marketing materials are distributed to clinicians and consumers worldwide to help them make informed treatment choices.

5. Sources to corroborate the impact

[A] Launch of Appatella https://digitallabs.mmu.ac.uk/what-we-do/products/appatella/, 2018.

[B] Letter from Pedorthic Technology Limited, Hong Kong

[C] Letter form Head of the Arthroscopy and Sports Injury Unit, Hospital Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

[D] Impact of the Ladder of Intervention, PASS concept and work on Orthotic Walkers from DJO Asia Pacific.

[E] Educational videos viewed over 15,000 time on YouTube

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vVYrHsnfMAg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcfnXHGmYKQ

[F] Evidence of change in practice and policy in New Zealand, 2019

[G] Letter from the CEO of the Tonic Asia Group healthcare centers, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

[H] Letter Changing clinical practice in South Africa

[I] Evidence of inclusion of our work on Orthotic Walkers as marketing evidence and its impact on South Korea reimbursement

Submitting institution
University of Central Lancashire
Unit of assessment
24 - Sport and Exercise Sciences, Leisure and Tourism
Summary impact type
Technological
Is this case study continued from a case study submitted in 2014?
No

1. Summary of the impact

Our research has had a substantial impact on developing and implementing equine surface testing protocols and terminology for the Fédération Equestre Internationale (FEI). These testing protocols have been used to certify Olympic Games surfaces at Rio de Janeiro and Tokyo and are currently being developed into international standards. Our work is being disseminated globally via media outlets, professional governing bodies, pro-riders and fellow equine educators, which is transforming awareness of equine surfaces and their underlying research evidence base. The impact of our research with multiple collaborators is far reaching, from using Hobbs’ methods to investigate ‘Usan telmen’ gait in Mongolia, through enhancing the breeding industry in Sweden, to educating dressage judges in the USA.

2. Underpinning research

Equestrian sports research at the University of Central Lancashire was initiated in 2001 by Hobbs, who continues to lead this area of research today with support from a Research Associate, a number of other non-equine staff who have complementary skills and many external collaborators. The team have led 12 bids and supported one funded bid and consultancy projects. The focus of the University of Central Lancashire’s equine research has been in three key areas: advancing knowledge of equestrian surface function and dysfunction, developing robust methods of equine locomotion analysis, and quantifying the functional demands of equine sports’ performance for the horse and rider.

Assessment of equestrian sports’ surface performance began at the University of Central Lancashire with studies involving the hoof-surface interaction. Initial findings suggested that: moisture substitutes, such as wax, alter grip characteristics, surface preparation can alter locomotion patterns, and banking a turn allows the horse to remain more perpendicular to the surface, which reduces the asymmetry between inside and outside limbs at faster gaits [1]. Surface functional properties influence gait, but appropriate standard methods of measurement were not available for equestrian arenas in 2010. With this in mind, Hobbs directed a number of projects to validate equipment and procedures for measuring and monitoring equestrian competition surfaces, from initial design through to installation and maintenance [2, 3]. Following on from this, Hobbs developed some of the complex objective measures that were compared to existing subjective evaluations [4]. This study formed the foundation for the development of appropriate measurements and measurement thresholds for show jumping competition surfaces.

In order to quantify the functional demands of equine sports performance for the horse and rider, Hobbs developed a long-standing collaborative relationship with Prof. Hilary Clayton (Michigan State University). Together they have developed three-dimensional full-body models of the horse that have allowed them to investigate aspects of locomotion and balance when performing different gaits and movements [5]. They have also developed advanced methods of studying multi-dimensional time continuous data to improve knowledge and understanding of the nuances of equine conformation and motion [6]. The methods developed in [6] aimed to create simplified visual images of limb function from complex numerical data that veterinarians, farriers and other practitioners could easily interpret. The focus of this body of work has been firstly to quantify the demands of high-level movements for elite dressage horses [5] with complex movement, including piaffe which is currently under investigation. Secondly, to observe and measure asymmetric hoof growth and quantify the extent of locomotor asymmetry [6]. Asymmetric sports horses and racehorses are commonly found in the population and horses with asymmetric feet are associated with shortened competition careers. Quantifying the consequences of morphological and/or physiological differences, alongside discipline-specific demands for competitive horses, will likely reduce injury risks as the evidence is more widely disseminated. It will also improve selection criteria for equine athletes, leading to increased welfare and career longevity.

3. References to the research

  1. Hobbs, S.J., Licka, T. And Polman, R.J.C. (2011). The difference in kinematics of horses walking, trotting and cantering on a flat and banked 10 m circle. Equine Veterinary Journal. 43: 6: 686-694. DOI: 10.1111/j.2042-3306.2010.00334.x

  2. Holt, D., Northrop, A., Owen, A., Martin, J. and Hobbs, S.J. (2014). Use of surface testing devices to identify potential risk factors for synthetic equestrian surfaces. Procedia Engineering. DOI: 10.1016/j.proeng.2014.06.160.

  3. Lewis, K., Northrop, A., Crook, G., Mather, J., Martin, J., Clayton, H.M., Roepstorff, L., Peterson, M. and Hobbs, S.J. (2015). Validation of an original piece of equipment for the measurement of rotational shear properties in equine arena surfaces. Biosystems Engineering. DOI: 10.1016/j.biosystemseng.2015.07.006.

  4. Hernlund, E., Egenvall, A., Hobbs, S.J., Peterson, M.L., Northrop, A.J., Bergh, A., Martin, J.H. and Roepstorff, L. (2017) Comparing subjective and objective evaluation of show jumping competition and warm-up arena surfaces. The Veterinary Journal, 227: 49-57. ISSN 1090-023.

  5. Clayton, H.M. and Hobbs, S.J. (2017). An exploration of strategies used by dressage horses to control moments around the center of mass when performing passage. PeerJ, 5. e3866.

  6. Hobbs, S.J., Nauwelaerts, S., Sinclair, J., Clayton, H.M., Back, W. (2018). Sagittal plane fore hoof unevenness is associated with fore and hindlimb asymmetrical force vectors in the sagittal and frontal planes. PLOS ONE, 13 (8). e0203134.

*all peer-reviewed journals

4. Details of the impact

Development of a framework for FEI certification

Following the London 2012 Olympics, the Fédération Equestre Internationale (FEI), the world governing body for equestrian sports, initiated a footing project to continue the scientific work on surfaces that evolved from the games. Soon after, Hobbs was asked to take the lead in writing a white paper [A], based on her research [1]. For Hobbs this became a two-year project, as her vision for the paper was to provide a comprehensive resource for the equestrian community by combining current scientific knowledge with a framework from which surface standards could be developed. Together with an extensive review of intrinsic and extrinsic factors that influence welfare and performance [1], the white paper also included a review of existing and new surface testing methods [2], engineering definitions applied to surface testing, a certification framework and layman’s surface terminology for a new industry standard. The development of layman’s terms to describe the functional properties of surfaces was an important step towards certification, as scientific (objective) measurements could then be directly applied to layman’s terms, which provided a universal language of communication [B]. In 2014, the FEI made the white paper freely available to the worldwide equestrian community as a reference and educational source. Examples of its reach and influence can be found globally (i.e. Canada, USA, Australia) to include over 40 independent articles that discuss and critique the information, concepts and proposed framework. For example, Norton (2015) concluded for Horse Sport magazine that:

**‘The Equine Surfaces White Paper discussed a great number of aspects that must be considered when discussing optimal footing. However, there are such large gaps in our knowledge that specific recommendations for each discipline can’t be made at this time. The authors hope by educating trainers and riders as to how surface conditions affect the biomechanical performance of our horses, injuries can be prevented.**’ [C]

Producing protocols for the certification process

The FEI began a consultation process with industry following the launch of the white paper, with Hobbs as one of the main scientific advisors [D]. To progress the development of protocols, one study focused on defining acceptable thresholds for field based, objective measurements of show jumping competition surfaces [4], whilst other studies [2, 3] were used to inform the inclusion of laboratory-based tests and the development of surface maintenance procedures. The scientific work in [4] also raised awareness of surface terminology and function in the 198 riders taking part in nine elite competitions at six European venues. In 2016-17 Hobbs and St George were commissioned by the FEI to develop a complete set of protocols for surface certification. The protocols were underpinned by the scientific work and comprised of 38 separate documents in total. The in-situ protocols were piloted at the Olympic Games and the World Equestrian Games (WEG) (France, Brazil and USA). The materials and track-in-a-box protocols that were developed were used in the selection process for the tenders submitted for the Tokyo Olympic surface. The in-situ protocols were used at the Tokyo test event and will be used at the Olympic Games in 2021 [D]. The in-situ protocol has recently been adapted for an American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standard (F3400-19) and the suite of materials, track-in-a-box and certification protocols are currently under consideration by voting members of the ASTM. The benefits of measuring surfaces to a defined standard for events, horses and riders was highlighted at Tryon, USA (WEG 2018). Prior to the WEG, three horses fell during competition in the main arena [E]. After extensive testing, a new main arena and surface were proposed and used for the games, which was hailed as a huge success. Implementation of the certification process on a wider scale was agreed by the Footing Standards Working Group in April 2019 [D]. They proposed that all 5* competitions (Approximately 90 worldwide/year) should have in-situ surface certification at the start of each competition. This recommendation is awaiting FEI approval by the Jumping Committee and the General Assembly and will result in a rule change if approved. In addition, the Working Group recommended that surface providers are given the opportunity to have their products FEI certified using the materials testing and track-in-a-box testing protocols. Surface evaluation using functional properties terminology is also embedded into the new FEI Event Classification system [D] that is designed to ensure that standards are maintained at all FEI competitions. Test results and surface evaluations are already influencing perception of acceptable surfaces and of maintenance practices, with practitioners more commonly favouring softer, well cushioned surfaces. Ultimately, this will reduce injury risk for the horse, as hard surfaces are a contributory factor in the development of overuse injuries (2).

Increasing awareness of factors that influence horse health, welfare and performance

Increasing awareness of intrinsic and extrinsic factors beyond the white paper that can impact on the health and performance of horses is also a key driver for the University of Central Lancashire’s equine research team. In order to increase the reach of our work, a day of workshops were produced so that the footage and presentations could be used as part of the launch of the FEI Campus, a free educational website, targeted towards the international equestrian community [F]. The FEI Campus was launched in 2017 and by March 2018 it had already attracted 15,541 visitors (3,117 registered members) worldwide who had engaged with the learning materials which included all four presentations from the workshops [F]. The University of Central Lancashire’s contribution included research work on asymmetry [6] and balance [5] in horses and further dissemination of the proposed equipment and techniques to be used for equestrian surface certification [A][2]. A key element of embedding new knowledge that will benefit horse welfare is through our work with scientific practitioners. Hobbs supervised the doctoral research of Dr Simon Curtis, Fellow of the Worshipful Company of Farriers. Since successfully graduating, Curtis has visited 15 different countries in Europe, North and South America, Australasia and Asia to date, to present the work to over 2000 farriers, vets and breeders. The research includes techniques developed in [6] on asymmetric hoof growth, foot balance, loading patterns and hoof distortion.

In March 2018, Curtis was acknowledged for his efforts, receiving the Colin Spedding Award from HRH Princess Anne at the National Equine Forum. The impact of his work in influencing practice was captured in a survey in 2018 [G], showing that his dissemination of the research had reached practitioners from every continent. From the survey, 95.7% of 516 respondents reported that Curtis’ research has positively influenced their knowledge, skills development and/ or practice within the equine industry. An example of the impact of his research is illustrated by this quote from the Programme Manager of BYS Farrier School in Sweden.

‘Simon's study means a lot to our development work on hoof care, correction of foals and various working methods within the hoof care sector in Sweden. His thesis is also of great importance for our future breeding work.’ [G].

Educating students and practitioners on aspects of equine locomotion and their demands on the musculoskeletal system of the horse from our research findings [1, 2, 5, 6] is a priority for the research team. Along with the workshops and seminars given by the research team, Hobbs’ collaborator Hilary Clayton (Michigan State University), a scientist, vet, dressage trainer and Grand Prix rider also disseminates our collaborative research [5] to the equestrian community to aid improvements in training practice [H]. This includes an annual presentation to judges at the US Dressage Federation Convention and many workshops and training sessions worldwide. Our research is embedded in equine science course curriculums at a local, national and international level [I] providing enhanced knowledge and understanding to current and future equine practitioners. Our methods of calculating moments around the centre of mass and then using them to investigate balance and locomotion [5] also has reach beyond the gaits performed by sports horses. A member of the Mongolian ambling horse federation remarked on using these techniques to investigate the ‘Usan telmen’ gait:

‘I truly inspired by your work which the techniques that used in these studies and logic explanations, result are sufficient to understand and explore the behavior of other gaits too.’ [I]

One of the keys to reaching stakeholders globally is using gold open access journals, which Hobbs and Clayton have prioritised wherever possible [5, 6]. This allows further dissemination to occur through lay article reviews and helps to spread important messages originating from the scientific work as widely as possible, such as the messages in [5] highlighted by HorseTalk, New Zealand:

‘Given the complexities involved, it is not surprising that some horses fail to learn the biomechanical skills necessary for passage….Researchers Hilary Clayton and Sarah Jane Hobbs… writing in the journal PeerJ, said the slow speed of passage challenged the horse’s ability to control the sagittal-plane moments around the center of mass.’ [H].

Awareness of equine surface testing and surface standards for show jumping competitions has already made an impression on equestrian practitioners within the sport of eventing. Eventing is primarily performed on turf surfaces, which can vary considerably in their functional properties. Course designers, organisers, riders and other practitioners within eventing have recognised the benefits in having a quantifiable description of the ‘going’ prior to an event, particularly for the cross-country phase [J]. Cross-country courses are undulating and up to approximately 6.8 km in length, which limits the possibility of using identical equipment and methods to those used in show jumping competitions at all but the highest level. As such, Hobbs and Graydon, together with ex-junior team British Eventing (BE) veterinarian Mark Lucey, and colleagues from Nottingham Trent University, tested 26 affiliated BE courses with a range of surface measuring devices over the 2019 eventing season in the UK. The results from this initial work are driving the establishment of standard methods and equipment for measuring cross country turf surfaces in the future. This work has already been highly praised by stakeholders, such as Philip Herbert (accredited BE course designer):

‘Thank you and all of your team for this most comprehensive report. I am most impressed with the trouble you have gone to and the amount of data you have recorded. You will be most welcome to come to Burghley, at any time in the future and if you require any assistance from me, in my capacity as BE Ground Condition Adviser, do please get in touch. I wish you every success with this process in the future, I am sure it will be a valuable asset to equestrian sport.’ [J]

5. Sources to corroborate the impact

  1. Hobbs, S.J., Northrop, A., Mahaffey, C., Martin, J., Clayton, H.M., Murray, R., Roepstorff, L. and Peterson, M. (2014). Equine Surfaces White Paper. FEI Publications. http://www.fei.org/fei/about-fei/publications/fei-books.

  2. Footing Project History. Discussion of definitions and terminology.

  3. Results from Google internet search for Equine Surfaces White paper.

  4. Examples of FEI Correspondence. 1) Meeting minutes FEI Footing Standards Meeting, 28-29th July 2015, 2) E-mail from Tim Hadaway, FEI with regarding Tokyo tender process, 24th Oct 2017, 3) Letter of support from Harald Muller, FEI, 1st Feb 2018, 4) E-mail from Somesh Dutt with video link to promote surface standards,16th Oct 2019

  5. Glavan, A. (2017). Footing Concerns Addressed During Tryon International Equestrian Center CSI***. Chronofhorse.com magazine article

  6. Improving Sports Horse Performance: Bridging the gap between science and practice (2015-18). 1) Evidence of workshop on Eventbrite, 2) Workshop attendee numbers, 3) FEI Campus website. Online resources (video/learning tools) for all four presentations from Improving Sports Horse Performance: Bridging the gap between science and practice, 4) FEI Campus – Enrolment March 2018. E-mail from Clio Tettoni (FEI).

  7. Hobbs, S.J., St George, L. and Curtis, S. (2019). Evaluation of the impact and reach of Dr. Simon Curtis’ research on the equine industry: A survey of practitioners. Updated with e-mails

  8. HorseTalk. (2017). Challenges in dressage: Complexities of passage identified by researchers. www.horsetalk.co.nz magazine article.

  9. E-mail and online evidence of use of scientific work within curriculum from colleges, institutions and members of Researchgate. (2020).

  10. Selection of e-mails from British Eventing testing. (2019).

Submitting institution
University of Central Lancashire
Unit of assessment
24 - Sport and Exercise Sciences, Leisure and Tourism
Summary impact type
Societal
Is this case study continued from a case study submitted in 2014?
No

1. Summary of the impact

This Impact Case Study demonstrates how our student volunteerism methods have addressed UN objectives and the interlinking priorities of governing bodies within sport. We co-created the blueprint for the University Olympic Volunteer Centres within 26 Russian Universities, which engaged 27,000 volunteers for the Sochi 2014 Winter Olympic Games. Volunteer Centres within Universities in the Russian Federation was a new concept and there was little knowledge around the recruitment, management and support of volunteers. A thriving volunteer movement developed in Russia after the games that used the Sochi model we developed. Using the same model, 17,040 volunteers were recruited for the 2018 FIFA World Cup. Our innovative student mentoring and peer leadership programmes based on our research have developed influential peer leaders and educated and transformed the lives of thousands of children and young people in Pakistan, Oman and Zambia, as well as 900 orphans in Morocco. These innovations in peer leadership programmes have also improved the life chances and world perspectives of 400 unaccompanied refugee children in Lesvos.

2. Underpinning research

The Centre for Volunteering and Community Leadership (CVCL) was developed in 1999 at the University of Central Lancashire. The CVCL exists to develop compassionate socially responsible graduates through the delivery of research-informed social action and student knowledge exchange for development, in ways which address the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) 3 Good Health and Wellbeing, 4 Quality Education, 5 Gender Equality, 10 Reduced Inequalities and 16 Strategic Partnerships for Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions. The CVCL also aims to address the priorities of international sporting organisations such as the International Olympic Committee (IOC) to encourage and support the promotion of women in sport at all levels and in all structures, to encourage and support initiatives blending sport with culture and education and to cooperate with competent public or private organisations and authorities to place sport at the service of humanity and promote peace. As well as addressing the Social Legacy, FIFA priorities concerning diversity, health, access for all and human resources. The underpinning research for this case study was developed by a multidisciplinary academic team working within some of the most deprived communities, locally, nationally, and internationally. Their research processes are influenced by Freirean critical pedagogy based on equal dialogical relationships. Their concepts of mentoring, influenced by their research findings [1], are based on positive change, not production.

Development of an ‘action learning tool kit’

Emancipatory Action Research (EAR) is often employed as an appropriate methodology, which is applied in different situations and contexts. In 2007, the CVCL used EAR to successfully deliver a community education programme to a group of 26 South Asian women from a deprived area of Burnley [2]. The challenges identified through the EAR process, in order to provide an inclusive programme for these women, were significant and initial interventions were needed to engage the women on the programme. These pioneering women graduated and now act as role models and mediators. Through experiential learning the CVCL team created an ‘action learning tool kit’ using the successes and reflections from this inclusive programme to develop the toolkit and create new programmes for use with other groups.

Further research projects have adapted the toolkit. Transformational leadership training techniques combined with Paulo Freire pedagogy were used to develop and deliver a peer leadership programme for young people in Pakistan [3]. The overall aim of the project was to create regional and provincial contingents of young peer educators, supported by undergraduate volunteers, who would then deliver training in leadership and key skills. Using an EAR methodology, student volunteer peer researchers, or ‘animateurs’, delivered a five-day workshop through the Global Youth Leaders (GYL) Programme. GYL is an unaffiliated body of like-minded individuals and organisations, sharing the common goal of empowering young people for positive change through peer education and leadership. This workshop opened up a much wider range of possibilities than youth leadership training alone. In partnership with University of Gujrat students, Melling and Khan produced a development framework that was the foundation of the universities ‘tool kit’ for developing leadership skills and Freire-influenced social action. The toolkit was implemented through CVCL educational and peer leadership programmes. Further studies were used to evaluate the methods, implementation and impact [4] and to explore their effectiveness in a wider social context beyond the classroom.

Student Mentoring in the Community

CVCL promotes an ethos that mentoring interventions are a means of allowing young people to enhance their social and personal skills. This enables them to reflect on and learn from the process and accumulate social capital. This research led to the development of innovative youth-led projects, including student mentoring within the community. Having adopted this approach to mentoring, Melling and Gurjee [1] assessed the benefits of student mentoring for the students and the mentees engaged in a 12-month project. Their results highlighted that a mentee-centred-approach provided ‘invisible gifts’ of key skills for lifelong learning and employability for the mentors and positive personal development outcomes for the mentees. The mentor-mentee relationship was central to Olsson’s research [5], that focused on coach mentoring systems, which have become more widespread in sport. This led to the CVCL developing new approaches and tools to support coach mentoring and development. Most recently, Gurjee [6] has explored the interaction that takes place between student mentor and mentee, developing a conceptual framework of the key components of the mentoring interface.

3. References to the research

  1. Melling, A. and Gurjee, R. (2013) ‘Researching the Impact of Student Mentoring in the Community’. International Journal of Social Work and Human Services Practice, 1.1. pp.1-8.*

  2. Melling, A. and Khan, W. (2013) ‘‘Crossing the Road’: The value of inclusive pedagogical practice for South Asian women in Burnley, East Lancashire’. Widening Participation and Lifelong Learning, 14.3. pp.190-201.*

  3. Khan, W. and Melling, A. (2015) Pakistan in Praxis: The Development of a Peer Education Programme as a Tool Kit in Developing Young People for Critical Consciousness. In: Paulo Freire: The Global Legacy. Counterpoints. Peter Lang, New York. ISBN 9781454196501

  4. Ali, Yasmeen (2018) Using a Freirean approach within the Global Youth Solutions programme. In: Paulo Freire and Transformative Education: Changing Lives and Transforming Communities. Palgrave Macmillan UK, London, pp. 203-214. ISBN 9781137542496

  5. Olsson, C., Cruickshank, A., and Collins, D. (2017) ‘Making mentoring work: The need for rewiring epistemology’. Quest, 69.1. pp. 50-64. ISSN 0033-629*

  6. Gurjee, R. (2020). An Investigation into Mentoring Relationships of HE Students in Community Settings, Journal of Peer Learning, 13. pp. 48-60. *

*indicates peer-reviewed articles

All outputs can be supplied by the HEI on request

4. Details of the impact

Development of a volunteer programme for sports mega-events

In 2010, Melling was contracted by the 2014 Winter Olympic Committee to create the blueprint and preparation training programme for Olympic Volunteer Centres within 26 Russian universities [A]. Volunteer Centres within universities was a new concept for the Russian Federation and there was little knowledge around the recruitment, management and support of volunteers. Melling worked with Sochi Organising committee for the Olympic Games to identify appropriate institutions and using the ‘action learning toolkit’ [2, 3] and peer leadership programme model [4] they co-created a training programme to ensure standards of excellence in volunteer management. For the first time in the history of the Olympic movement, selecting and training Games volunteers was carried out through Volunteer Centres based at educational institutions throughout the country. The programme formalised volunteering within the Russian Federation through the engagement of 27,000 volunteers and was one of the most important outcomes of the 2014 Winter Olympics. The Official International Olympic Committee (IOC) Report on Sochi 2014 Vol two stated:

"The Sochi 2014 Games helped revive volunteerism in Russia and brought it to a completely new level of development. The Sochi 2014 Volunteer Programme could be called one of the most important elements of the Games legacy." [B]

The benefits of the programme also had far reaching impact on the lives of Russian people beyond the Games: “When Sochi began the bidding process in 2005, the concept of volunteering simply did not exist in Russia,” explains Dmitry Chernyshenko, President and CEO of the Sochi 2014 Organising Committee. “Now, the volunteer movement is thriving, with a quarter of a million Russians regularly participating in volunteer activity.” [C]

Further to Melling’s contribution to the Sochi 2014 Volunteer Centre concept, the CVCL was also consulted on the development of a volunteer legacy programme for the FIFA 2018 World Cup in Moscow. The University of Central Lancashire signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with Moscow State Social University and Melling collaborated with former Head of the Sochi 2014 Volunteer Programme, Anton Lopukhin, Acting Vice Rector of the Moscow State Social University, on the development of an inclusive legacy programme, which would create benefits for community projects around disability and social justice. Representatives from Moscow City Government then visited the University of Central Lancashire on a fact-finding mission to explore best practice in relation to mega-sports volunteering [D]. Using the Sochi model, 17,040 volunteers were recruited for the 2018 FIFA World Cup.

The media predicted that the FIFA 2018 World Cup in Moscow would be tarnished by racism and hooliganism. This did not happen. The World Cup was a success, where all visitors were made welcome and the game was characterised by friendliness. This was due in part to the culture of volunteerism built on an ethos of social inclusion. As Patrick Jennings from BBC Sport stated in 2018:

“In many ways, Russia was the perfect World Cup host. A vast country where there is so much to uncover. The organisation was superb, thanks in no small part to the thousands of volunteers who helped visitors get by.” [E]

Transforming lives through peer leadership

From 2014 to 2020 the work of the CVCL has created a network of student volunteer peer researchers and leaders delivering research-informed knowledge exchange within the UK, the Russian federation, Pakistan, Oman, and Zambia. Participants in this network have strong connections with international agencies and policymakers: Anaisa Baig from the University of Gujrat Centre for Civil Society was invited to represent Pakistan at the G(irls)8 Summit: Zuleikha Chikh, CVCL University of Central Lancashire, became Muslim Sports Leader of the Year, 2019 in the Muslim Women in Sports Powerlist: and Wajid Khan, University of Central Lancashire CVCL, became MEP for Northwest England and sits on the committee for Human Rights within the European Parliament. Chikh’s postgraduate research on women and leadership in sport is directly addressing IOC and UN SDG priorities regarding gender equality.

The Global Youth Solutions (GYS) peer leadership model developed by CVCL [4] has had an impact which has transcended Sochi 2014. In 2013 the GYS programme engaged with the University of Gujrat in Pakistan, resulting in an international student led conference in 2014, where students at the University of Gujrat co-created a conceptual university volunteer centre based on the Sochi model, with the mission of delivering peer research and leadership education addressing structural inequalities highlighted by the SDGs, including 10 Reduced Inequalities. This work led to the development of a new research Centre, the Centre for Civil Society within the University of Gujrat [F], which was ratified in 2014 by the Vice Chancellor, Professor Mohammad Nizamuddin, now the Head of the Pakistan Higher Education Commission. This resulted in a culture shift around formalised student volunteer knowledge exchange and peer-led research in the Gujrat Region of Pakistan. The GYS model was applied in Oman between 2014 and 2017, engaging 260 Omani Students as peer-research leaders. The programme resulted in a culture shift in volunteerism within Omani HEI’s and the development of a learning community of active volunteers. On the strength of this, Nizwa University forged a MoU with the University of Central Lancashire [G1, G2]. Closer to home, in 2014 the CVCL was approached by the Traveller Education Service to develop an educational inclusion project with the Traveller community in Preston. The GYS programme facilitators worked on the site with young people to deliver a story-telling project about Traveller sports, experience, culture, and how the young people saw their place in the world. In the spirit of Freirean pedagogy, representatives from the Traveller community have formed an ongoing dialogue with undergraduates, engaging on Traveller culture, rights, and social justice [H]. Collaborating with Traveller communities has richly informed research and pedagogical approaches, thus influencing emerging work with local communities high on the multiple deprivation index, such as Shadsworth, Blackburn with Darwen, East Lancashire, and Allerdale and Copeland District, West Cumbria.

Another recent example includes the GYS 2019 project ‘Letters from Lesvos’, where CVCL student peer researchers contributed to addressing the six United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) priorities for reform. Many unaccompanied refugee children had undertaken perilous journeys across the sea and experienced significant trauma before their arrival at Lesvos. This experience impacted on the children’s confidence and trust in humanity. The aim of the project was to co-create new knowledge with the children, thus supporting a positive change in the children’s world view and development of both self-advocacy and peer-advocacy. To operationalise the project, the GYS team developed strategic partnerships with UNHCR, related NGOs, and the University of the Aegean, whose staff and students collaborated on a FIFA initiated football skills programme for refugees with Barcelona FC. The real impacts, however, transcend the formal structures of policy and practice. The children benefited from the project in several ways, but the greatest change was in their world view through the knowledge that the University of Central Lancashire staff and students cared enough to share their skills. In 2019, one child said:

“Despite the war, we can see that good people exist in the world”; “You make us very happy.”. [I]

Sport as a mechanism for international dialogue

Since 2014, over 100 University of Central Lancashire student volunteers collaborated with Sport in Action, a Zambian sports non-governmental organization. This collaboration enabled peer leaders from Sport in Action to deliver life skills programmes in Kabwe and Lusaka, directly impacting the lives of over 3,500 young people [J]. Local schools have reported further impacts in terms of increased classroom attendance and educational engagement post intervention. Students with specialist skills in Media and Film production, Journalism and Publishing have helped to enhance the profile and consequently the impact of Sport in Action, nationally and internationally, by producing high quality marketing literature, YouTube trailers, video documentaries and publications. Furthermore, using a student mentoring approach [1, 5] Sports Coaching and Sport Studies students co-delivered the development and delivery of community activity and health programmes in Kabwe and Lusaka addressing HIV and Hepatitis B, impacting on the lives of approximately 1,000 individuals. Student volunteer Physiotherapists have maintained the development and delivery of short first aid and basic injury prevention workshops in partnership with Sport in Action Peer Leaders in Kabwe and worked on placements at the IOC Regional Development Centre in Lusaka. The impact of this has been the co creation of new health education programmes. Latterly, Sexual Health students have been based in Lusaka supporting the delivery of key sexual health education messages to young people and supporting the education of teachers and sports leaders. This activity impacted on 5000 individuals and its success has been demonstrated through increased dissemination of key messages. Sport in Action are now working with the University of Central Lancashire volunteer students on programmes on Gender Equality and combating violence towards young women.

The Centre Sauvegarde de l’Enfance d’Agadir is a Boys’ and Girls’ orphanage in Morocco whose purpose is to care for and support young people who have no family or have either been abandoned by their parents or referred to the Centre by the juridical court system. The Centre positively impacts the lives of hundreds of children throughout Agadir, currently caring for 96 boys and 80 girls. Utilizing peer mentoring methodologies [1, 5] student volunteer peer mentors and CVCL staff work with approximately 180 young people per year and support over 25 staff members to help deliver key life-skills and health messages [K]. Stakeholders such as the CVCL play a crucial role in supporting organizational development and sustainability. The Centre has worked closely with CVCL to create a strong partnership and to use sport as a tool to engage with the children. Since 2014, CVCL has added significant capacity to the Centre in terms of knowledge exchange and in the development of a sustainable structure.

Nawal Rais, the CEO, has stated that children displaying behavioural issues and not attending has significantly reduced from 50% to 13%, with many now regularly attending school and demonstrating a positive attitude to learning.

Further change in terms of increased extra-curricular interventions including football and basketball have also been reported on national TV in Morocco. Finally, to ensure a lasting and sustained impact the University of Central Lancashire have supported the Centre in making physical activity a core element of the curriculum.

5. Sources to corroborate the impact

A. Sochi 2014 Consultancy Contract

B. IOC Report Vol:2, 2014

C. https://www.olympic.org/news/intangible-legacies-of-sochi-2014-already-being-felt

D. https://www.uclan.ac.uk/news/uclan_experts_aid_russian_world_cup_preparations.php

E. https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/44787166

F. Report on the Impacts of the 2nd Youth Leadership Training Workshop at UoG

G. GYS Oman Feedback

G.1. Day 1 Feedback

G.2. Day 2 Feedback

H. Gypsy Roma Traveller Collaboration email 4/19

I. Times Higher Awards 2020, Shortlist.

J. Sport in Action Annual Report (2018) Zambia

K. Football as an International Dialogue: Centre Sauvegarde de l’enfance d’Agadir

Showing impact case studies 1 to 4 of 4

Filter by higher education institution

UK regions
Select one or more of the following higher education institutions and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.
No higher education institutions found.
Institutions

Filter by unit of assessment

Main panels
Select one or more of the following units of assessment and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.
No unit of assessments found.
Units of assessment

Filter by continued case study

Select one or more of the following states and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.

Filter by summary impact type

Select one or more of the following summary impact types and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.

Filter by impact UK location

UK Countries
Select one or more of the following UK locations and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.
No UK locations found.
Impact UK locations

Filter by impact global location

Continents
Select one or more of the following global locations and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.
No global locations found.
Impact global locations

Filter by underpinning research subject

Subject areas
Select one or more of the following underpinning research subjects and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.
No subjects found.
Underpinning research subjects