Skip to main

Impact case study database

The impact case study database allows you to browse and search for impact case studies submitted to the REF 2021. Use the search and filters below to find the impact case studies you are looking for.

Search and filter

Filter by

  • Oxford Brookes University
   None selected
  • 5 - Biological Sciences
   None selected
   None selected
   None selected
   None selected
   None selected
   None selected
Waiting for server
Download currently selected sections for currently selected case studies (spreadsheet) (generating)
Download currently selected case study PDFs (zip) (generating)
Download tags for the currently selected case studies (spreadsheet) (generating)
Currently displaying text from case study section
Showing impact case studies 1 to 4 of 4
Submitting institution
Oxford Brookes University
Unit of assessment
5 - Biological Sciences
Summary impact type
Technological
Is this case study continued from a case study submitted in 2014?
No

1. Summary of the impact

At Oxford Brookes University (OBU), Groome has developed novel, patented monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) that have significantly increased the sensitivity, reliability and speed of measurement of anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH). This provides an assay to assess women’s fertility that does not depend on the menstrual cycle and underpins personalised in vitro fertilisation (IVF) treatments. These antibodies are licensed to Beckman Coulter and sub-licensed to [text removed for publication] and others, who have developed and launched clinical diagnostic assays for AMH based on OBU’s antibodies. Clinicians and healthcare providers worldwide use these assays to assess ovarian reserve, optimise IVF treatments, and diagnose and monitor ovarian granulosa cell tumours to the benefit of millions of women around the world. Royalty income of over [text removed for publication] between August 2013 and July 2020 was received by OBU, indicative of cumulative sales of over [text removed for publication].

2. Underpinning research

Anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) is a dimeric glycoprotein made by the granulosa cells of the ovary, where it is pivotal for follicular growth and ovarian function. In women, AMH levels correlate with follicle counts. AMH is accepted globally as a direct serum biomarker of ovarian reserve and, as such, is used clinically to assess and monitor the reproductive potential of women.

Groome’s contribution to the research and clinical diagnostic applications of AMH has been through the development of innovative mAbs that underpin the accurate and reliable measurement of AMH, and its detection in serum. In 2000, Professor Axel Themmen, Professor of Experimental Endocrinology and Medical Education of Erasmus University (The Netherlands), one of the leading researchers on AMH at the time, invited Groome to join a European Commission-funded grant called OvAGE (R1). Groome’s contribution to this project was to develop new mAbs and assays to measure AMH levels (R2, R3a, R3b). Building upon the project’s outcomes, a panel of novel mAbs to human AMH were developed and characterised by Groome in 2004, and a pair selected for development of an immunoassay (R4).

The innovation in Groome’s approach for AMH came from his decision to immunise not ordinary mice, but AMH knock-out mice with human AMH, thus eliciting the maximum number of mAbs to all epitopes of human AMH, rather than a pool limited to only epitopes that varied between human and mouse AMH. Subsequently, a pair of novel and highly sensitive mAbs was produced, F2B12H and F2B7A, which could be used to assay different biological samples (R3a). The first antibody (F2B12H) was used as a capture antibody and the second (F2B7A) was used as a detection antibody (R3a, R3b). Although there were other AMH mAb pairs available, such as the pair used in the AMH assay kit from Immunotech, France, Groome’s mAbs were directed to the mature region of the hormone, which confers greater resistance to proteolysis, a property that helps to reduce variability in the detection power of the immune assays (R2, R3a). He used these mAbs to develop an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to measure AMH levels in human serum. Details of the mAbs, their method of production and the development of the immunoassay are documented in a European patent granted in 2008 (R3a), a US patent granted in 2011 (R3b) and in a co-authored paper (R4) describing use of the human AMH assay to measure AMH in mice.

Further work demonstrated that the mAbs could be used to measure accurately a woman’s ovarian reserve in a variety of clinical conditions (R5, R6). Recognising the potential of mAbs for human clinical applications, the mAbs themselves, the hybridoma cell lines that produce them and the patent applications were licensed to [text removed for publication] in 2005 for commercialisation of a manual AMH immunoassay. In the same year, Beckman Coulter bought [text removed for publication] and OBU’s patent applications. The patent applications were progressed and the European and US patents were granted in due course (R3a, R3b). From 2005 to 2010 Beckman Coulter continued to sell the [text removed for publication] AMH manual ELISA and then, as [text removed for publication] was closed, relaunched a modified assay known as the Beckman Coulter Gen II AMH ELISA and an automated assay platform.

3. References to the research

R1. ‘Early development of ovarian follicles-determination of the timing of menopause’, OVAGE Grant agreement ID: QLK6-CT-2000-00338, 1 Jan 2001 to 31 Dec 2004. Funded under: FP5-LIFE QUALITY, Overall budget: EUR1,399,489. Groome, NP (Principal investigator at Oxford Brookes University)

R2. Weenen C, Laven JS, Von Bergh AR, Cranfield M, Groome NP, Visser JA, Kramer P, Fauser BC, Themmen AP. Anti-Müllerian hormone expression pattern in the human ovary: potential implications for initial and cyclic follicle recruitment. Molecular Human Reproduction, 2004, 10(2):77-83. DOI: 10.1093/molehr/gah015

R3. Patents

a) European Patent – EP1886140B1, Immunological assays and antibodies for anti-mullerian hormone, Groome, NP et al. Granted 18 September 2010. Licensed to Beckman Coulter. https://patents.google.com/patent/EP1886140B1/ar

b) US Patent – 7897350-B2, Immunological assays and antibodies for anti-mullerian hormone, Groome, NP et al. Granted 1 March 2011. Licensed to Beckman Coulter. https://patents.google.com/patent/US7897350B2/en

R4. Kenenaar ME, Meerasahib MF, Kramer P, van de Lang-Born BM, de Jong FH, Groome NP, Themmen AP, Visser JA. Serum anti-mullerian hormone levels reflect the size of the primordial follicle pool in mice. Endocrinology. 2006 147(7):3228-34. DOI: 10.1210/en.2005-1588.

R5. Anderson RA, Themmen AP, Al-Qahtani A , Groome NP, Cameron DA. The effects of chemotherapy and long-term, gonadotrophin suppression on the ovarian reserve in premenopausal women with breast cancer. Human Reproduction, 2006 21(10):2583-92. DOI: 10.1093/humrep/del201

R6. Lutchman SK, Mutturishna S, Stein RC, McGarrigle HH, Patel A, Parikh B, Groome NP, Daie MC, Chateerjee R. Predictors of ovarian reserve in young women with breast cancer. British Journal of Cancer, 2007 96(12):1808-16. DOI: 10.1038/sj.bjc.6603814

4. Details of the impact

The F2B12H and F2B7A mAbs and assay protocols to measure AMH levels in blood serum have had a significant influence on the reproductive health field. Between 2005 and 2013, manual AMH assays using Groome’s AMH mAbs facilitated clinical studies that uncovered potential routine clinical applications of serum AMH levels for the improvements of women’s’ fertility and reproductive health. The impacts described here relate to these applications and the worldwide use of Groome’s mAbs in automated AMH assays (Beckman Coulter Access, [text removed for publication] platforms) since 2014 (S1).

Impact on Clinicians and Healthcare Providers

In 2012, users of the Beckman Coulter Gen II AMH assay reported an issue with unreliable detection of AMH in fresh serum samples, resulting in an apparent increase in AMH levels over time while in storage. Groome, by then an Emeritus Professor at OBU, identified the problem and then worked with Beckman Coulter to rectify it (S2). This enabled Beckman Coulter to relaunch the Beckman Coulter AMH Gen II assay in a modified form in 2012 and launch a fully automated version on the Beckman Coulter Access platform in 2014. The impact of automating Groome’s AMH assay has been clearly stated by Professor Richard Fleming of Glasgow Centre for Reproductive Medicine Ltd: “The automated Access AMH will deliver increased sensitivity and precision, providing more reliable results for our patients, with absolute values with which we are familiar” (S3). Today, the automated assay is used routinely by IVF labs worldwide to aid prognosis and planning for couples with fertility problems (S4a, S4b). A survey completed by 796 globally distributed IVF clinics indicated that 60% of the respondent IVF clinics use the AMH assay as a first-line test; 54% reported it as the best test for evaluating ovarian reserve (S4b) and 89% reported that AMH results were extremely relevant or relevant to clinical practice (S4b).

The Beckman Coulter Access and [text removed for publication] automated AMH assays gained US Food and Drug Administration approval for diagnostic use in 2017 and 2018, respectively, allowing doctors to incorporate them into routine clinical practice in almost every country in the world. According to the 2018 survey of the College of American Pathologists (CAP), the main benefits of the automated platforms have been threefold: (i) shorter testing times (e.g. 18 minutes for [text removed for publication] AMH) compared with manual assays (3.5 hours) and traditional assays that measure follicle-stimulating hormone, luteinising hormone and oestrogen on the third day of a woman’s menstrual cycle; (ii) better performance than manual assays. Users state that “the [text removed for publication] and Beckman Coulter’s automated assay detect extremely low and high (0.03 to 23 ng/mL) and produce very little within-patient variability or lab-to-lab variability when using the same assay” (S5); (iii) accurate measurement of AMH. “AMH testing has been a huge advance in the field of reproductive medicine,” said Sara Barton, MD, reproductive endocrinologist at the Colorado Center for Reproductive Medicine in Denver. A major issue with the traditional testing approach for ovarian reserve was the duration of the assays (3 days). “But the problem with using only day-three hormone tests is by the time the FSH is abnormal, the prognosis for patients is compromised. They are often in perimenopausal transition. So while it offers an accurate identification of women with poor prognosis, it’s already too late to help some of them.” (S5). Karen Maruniak, Colorado Center for Reproductive Medicine stated: “The biggest advantage to us has been the time savings and the ability to run the test daily; before, we had to batch the manual test, which took three-and-a-half hours to run” (S5). Dr Robert Veve, US Speciality Labs, San Diego said: “The older test, with so many hands-on responsibilities, opened the door to errors… it is one of the main reasons why so much lab-to-lab variability was observed using the old assay” (S5). CAP surveys are highly significant because the CAP is a US programme that pools information on the productivity and proficiency of clinical laboratories.

The Beckman Coulter Access AMH Assay was winner of the 2015 Scientists’ Choice Award® for the Best New Clinical Laboratory Product of 2014, as an “innovative automated AMH test that is helping to improve fertility assessment and treatment” (S6).

Impact on Fertility and Health

AMH assays based on Groome’s mAbs have enabled millions of women across the world to make informed life decisions, such as freezing their eggs to give themselves a better chance of getting pregnant after chemotherapy for cancer (S7a) or later in life: “In addition to having less follicles, my level of AMH—which gives a snapshot of your ovarian reserve—was low… This didn't mean I wasn't a candidate for egg freezing, it just meant I'd have to pump myself up with more drugs to get these eggs to mature…” (S7b).

Fertility issues affect 1 in 10 couples globally. This number has increased steadily over recent decades, mainly because women are choosing to have their first child in their mid-30s or later, when their fertility is declining. AMH assays underpin personalised IVF treatments. Ovarian response to stimulation varies considerably from woman to woman and unexpected extreme responses may produce failure from hypostimulation or serious health problems due to hyperstimulation (hyperstimulation syndrome). These problems are avoided by using a recombinant follicle-stimulating hormone (Rekovelle®) dosing algorithm, which is based on a woman’s AMH level and body weight (S8). Rekovelle® is more effective than GONAL-f (follitropin alpha), another fertility medicine, at stimulating the ovaries of women undergoing controlled ovarian stimulation for IVF. A trial showed that around 31% of women (204 out of 665) treated with Rekovelle® became pregnant compared with around 32% of women (209 out of 661) treated with GONAL-f. Implantation rates were also similar: around 35% with Rekovelle® versus around 36% with GONAL-f (S8).

AMH assays are also used in paediatrics to investigate abnormal sexual development in boys (S9a). Pubertal delay and congenital hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (HH) share the same clinical manifestation of delayed sexual maturation in prepubertal boys. Levels of gonadotropin and testosterone are very low in prepubertal boys and therefore have little clinical significance. Hence, AMH measurements are useful in the differential diagnosis of pubertal delay and congenital HH. In boys with congenital HH, AMH concentrations are abnormally low; while in pubertal delay AMH concentrations are within the prepubertal reference interval. Low or undetectable levels of AMH are also typical of disorders such as cryptorchidism, anorchia or functional failure or Klinefelter syndrome (S9a).

In combination with Inhibin B or Inhibin A, AMH assays are also used to monitor ovarian tumour recurrence or progression. Elevated levels of any of these markers can indicate the presence of ovarian cancer (S9a). Other uses include the assessment of menopausal status and the ovarian function of women with polycystic ovarian syndrome (S9b).

Impact on Commerce

Beckman Coulter reported worldwide sales of the manual and automated AMH assays of [text removed for publication] from August 2013 to July 2020, giving OBU royalty income of [text removed for publication]. Three sub-licences covering human health, including the multinational healthcare company [text removed for publication], together with two sub-licences for animal health applications, have led to worldwide sales of [text removed for publication] between August 2013 and July 2020, the latter giving OBU royalty income of [text removed for publication] (S10).

5. Sources to corroborate the impact

S1. Automated AMH assay platforms using Groome’s monoclonal antibodies

  1. Beckman Coulter Access AMH assay: https://www.beckmancoulter.com/en/products/immunoassay/access-amh (launched in 2014, approved by FDA in 2017)

[text removed for publication]

S2. Modification of AMH assay protocol has produced new assay tools

Faye, S, Groome, N, Masica, R and Kertez, G, 2014, Abstract for Poster P-515 ‘Investigation and resolution of the effect of an interfering factor in the Beckman Coulter Anti-Müllerian Hormone (AMH) Gen II ELISA assay’, page e331, ESHRE meeting, Munich, Germany 29 June to 2 July. Available here

S3. Modified AMH assays are more accurate clinical tools

‘Automated Anti-Müllerian Hormone Test Available to Improve Fertility Assessment and Treatment’, SelectScience, 11 September 2014 [ Product News]

S4. Modified AMH assays are used by fertility clinics worldwide

  1. ‘Putting Patients at the Centre of Fertility Care’, James Coker (Reporter, European Medical Journal), EMG Health, 30 August 2018 [ link]

  2. Tobler, K.J., Shoham, G., Christianson, M.S. et al. Use of anti-mullerian hormone for testing ovarian reserve: a survey of 796 infertility clinics worldwide. Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics 32, 1441-1448 (2015). DOI: 10.1007/s10815-015-0562-7

S5. Satisfaction is high with new automated AMH assays

‘Satisfaction high with new automated AMH assays’, Valerie Neff Newitt, CAP Today, June 2018 [ link]

S6. Scientists’ Choice Award® to Beckman Coulter for Best New Clinical Laboratory Product 2014, SelectScience, 30 July 2015 [ Editorial Article]

S7. Increasing the chances to get pregnant later in life or after cancer treatment

  1. USC Fertility, Egg Freezing for Cancer Patients [ link]

  2. I’m Not Sure I Want Kids – That’s Why I Froze My Eggs’, Danielle Page, The Well by Northwell [ Women’s Health]

S8. New analysis of Rekovelle® data further supports use of AMH to personalise fertility treatment, Ferring Pharmaceuticals, 2 July 2018 [ Press Release]

S9. Further clinical uses of AMH – two examples

  1. Test ID: AMH1, Antimullerian Hormone, Serum, Mayo Clinic Laboratories [ link]

  2. Anti-Mullerian Hormone, Lab Tests Onlineuk [ link]

S10. Licences and Commercial Impact – Commercial and Knowledge Exchange Director, Research Business Development Office, Oxford Brookes University

Submitting institution
Oxford Brookes University
Unit of assessment
5 - Biological Sciences
Summary impact type
Environmental
Is this case study continued from a case study submitted in 2014?
No

1. Summary of the impact

Professor Anna Nekaris is a world leader in the conservation of endangered nocturnal primates, especially Asian lorises. Instrumental in driving changes to the legislation on the trade of CITES Appendix I-listed species in Japan, her work has also advanced the welfare of lorises in zoos and rescue centres worldwide. She has conserved their natural habitats in Asia, establishing a field site in Java (the Little Fireface Project) dedicated to their conservation through habitat restoration, installing 25 wildlife crossings and planting more than 10,000 trees, the training of future conservationists and education programmes for local communities, which have reached over 1,800 children across Western Indonesia. She has also increased global awareness of the plight of Asian lorises through social media campaigns and outreach activities.

2. Underpinning research

Since 2001, Professor Nekaris has provided key research insights that have actively contributed towards the conservation of a unique group of evolutionarily distinct primates known as the Asian lorises, which are endangered due to habitat loss, uses in traditional medicines and black magic, and the pet and photo prop trades. There are 12 species of small nocturnal animals found throughout South and Southeast Asia, seven of which Nekaris named or elevated from subspecies level and one of which has been included on the IUCN Primate Specialist group’s list of the World’s 25 Most Endangered Primates since 2010. Through Nekaris’ field site in West Java, Indonesia, the Little Fireface Project (LFP), where researcher presence and data collection have been continuous since 2012, has studied more than 75 individuals of these Critically Endangered primates in one of the last habitats where they are found.

Illegal trade in lorises: cultural underpinnings and the aggravating role of social media

Although globally-threatened loris species are protected by international laws and national laws in their range countries, their illegal and unsustainable trade remains a major conservation challenge. To develop more effective conservation management strategies, Nekaris and her team have examined the impact of cultural practices and beliefs on the illegal loris trade in South and Southeast Asia. Their analysis of international records and their own fieldwork for the last 26 years in Laos, Cambodia, Thailand, Sri Lanka and Indonesia has revealed strong culturally specific drivers of the trade, even within single countries. Thus, whilst the live loris trade is more prevalent in Laos, Cambodia and Thailand, poaching for traditional Asian medicine is the main driver of the illegal trade in Cambodia [R1]. These findings are important because conservation practices in Asia are often generalised, which undermines the effectiveness of measures to protect lorises. Nekaris’ work has also revealed how the internet fuels the demand for lorises as pets in Asia and elsewhere by portraying them as ‘cuddly’ animals. Using a novel approach, the Oxford Brookes University team analysed over 12,000 comments posted over a three-year period in response to a slow loris video shown on YouTube. Many viewers commented on how cute the animal was and one of the more common responses was “where can I get one?”, suggesting that the demand for slow lorises as pets in Asia and elsewhere is enhanced by social media users’ watching the primates in videos [R2]. Critically, this study identified the internet as a powerful tool to study public perceptions of threatened animals in consumer countries.

Diet and feeding behaviour of lorises

Rescued and captive lorises are plagued by ill health, including dental diseases, obesity and decreased fertility. In a survey of lorises in North American zoos, of all lorises kept, there was a 0% reproductive success for larger slow lorises and 2-3% for pygmy slow lorises. Recognising that identifying their in situ diet, nutritional requirements and feeding behaviour would inform the provision of appropriate food to captive lorises, Nekaris and her team investigated the dietary and feeding habits of wild animals in their natural habitats and found that they fed mostly on insects and plant exudates, with the greatest proportion of their identified food items being plant saps and gums [R3]. This diet is markedly different from the typical frugivorous diet that they received in zoos or rescue centres, which had likely contributed to their health and behavioural problems. Nekaris further demonstrated that captive lorises fed with gum had improved health, especially reduced dental disease, increased fertility and increased activity [R3].

Slow loris conservation

The greatest obstacles to the rehabilitation and reintroduction or translocation of rescued lorises are limited knowledge of their behavioural ecology, and the poor health and behavioural defects that rescued lorises often present. Nekaris and her collaborators examined these issues over a period of four years at the Little Fireface Project. With a very poor rate of reintroduction success (14 out of 18 animals died or disappeared), they noted the urgent need for wild behaviour studies before releasing animals to the wild. They further identified that issues such as gum in the diet, health checks, cage size and levels of stress during transit were critically important for the success of rehabilitation or translocation [R4]. These data were used also by Endangered Asian Species Trust in Vietnam, who went from an almost 100% death rate in reintroductions to almost 100% success. In a pioneering study in Java, Nekaris and her team also demonstrated the importance of water-pipe bridges to enable canopy connectivity in human-modified and fragmented landscapes. Implementation of the bridges extended the home range of slow lorises on average by 1.6-fold (2.57ha before, 4.11ha after), which increased the number of feeding trees visited [R5].

Slow loris venom

All nine recognised species of slow loris are venomous. This is particularly challenging for practitioners handling these animals in rescue centres and zoos, and another important reason why lorises are unsuitable as pets. Nekaris has published medical accounts of the impact of slow loris venom on humans. Further, Nekaris and her team, through an 8-year study of wounding patterns, territorial behaviour and agonistic encounters of a free-ranging population of Javan slow loris, have provided the first strong evidence that venom is used differentially by both sexes to defend territories and mates [R6]. The study of slow loris venom was first brought to public attention in 2012 by Nekaris in a BBC documentary highlighting her conservation and venom research, The Jungle Gremlins of Java ( https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01bcp7z).

3. References to the research

R1. Nekaris KAI, Shepherd CR, Starr CR, Nijman V (2010) Exploring cultural drivers for wildlife trade via an ethnoprimatological approach: a case study of slender and slow lorises ( Loris and Nycticebus) in South and Southeast Asia. American Journal of Primatology 72(10): 877-886. DOI: 10.1002/ajp.20842

R2. Nekaris KAI, Campbell N, Coggins TG, Rode EJ, Nijman V (2013) Tickled to death: analysing public perceptions of ‘cute’ videos of threatened species (slow lorises–Nycticebus spp.) on Web 2.0 Sites. PloS One 8(8): e69215. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0069215

R3. Cabana F, Nekaris KAI (2015) Diets high in fruits and low in gum exudates promote the occurrence and development of dental disease in pygmy slow loris (Nycticebus pygmaeus). Zoo Biology 34(6): 547-553. DOI: 10.1002/zoo.21245

R4. Moore RS, Wihermanto, Nekaris KAI (2014) Compassionate conservation, rehabilitation and translocation of Indonesian slow loris . Endangered Species Research 26: 93-102. DOI: 10.3354/esr00620.

R5. Birot H, Campera M, Imron MA, Nekaris KAI (2019) Artificial canopy bridges improve connectivity in fragmented landscapes: the case of Javan slow lorises in agroforest environment. American Journal of Primatology 82(4): e23076. DOI: 10.1002/ajp.23076.

R6. Nekaris KAI, Campera M, Nijman V, Birot H, Rode-Margono EJ, Fry BG, Weldon A, Wirdatet W, Imron MA (2020) Slow lorises use venom as a weapon in intraspecific competition. Current Biology 30(20): PR1252-R1253. doi: 10.1016/j.cub.2020.08.084.

4. Details of the impact

Nekaris’ work on slow lorises has improved the welfare and conservation of this critically endangered primate by: driving changes in legislation; the development of more effective rehabilitation, reintroduction and translocation protocols; and by increasing international awareness of the plight of slow lorises through social media and education programmes. Much of this has been accomplished through the Little Fireplace Project (LFP) and its field site in Java, Indonesia, as a platform to engage local communities, and zoos and rescue centres around the world.

Improved legislation to reduce the illegal trade of slow loris in Japan

Nekaris’ work has played a critical role in increasing awareness of the extent of the illegal loris trade in Japan [S1], which (according to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species, CITES) imports the greatest number of slow lorises in the world. Her work informed the Japanese campaign against the wildlife trade that led to improved legislation on the pet trade of animal species listed in CITES Appendix I, including slow lorises. As stated by the Secretary General of the Japan Wildlife Conservation Society: “ Prof. Anna Nekaris has directly contributed to reduction of illegal pet trade of slow lorises and animal welfare for over 10 years in Japan… Prof. Nekaris was instrumental in helping to change this legislation through collating data on international trade in slow lorises, including presenting a report from Japan Wildlife Conservation Society (JWCS) on seizures in Japan”. The Secretary General has also highlighted the impact of Nekaris on Japanese society’s awareness of slow lorises: “Prof. Nekaris cooperated with Japanese national broadcasting corporation (NHK) on filming for the TV documentary ‘Darwin Coming’ and this programme was broadcasted on February 2016 in Japan, which was seen by millions of viewers and was the most popular show of that day on Japanese television” [S2]. Following the approval of the new legislation in 2017, all permits issued in Japan must now have an expiry date and registered animals require a microchip [S3].

The Little Fireface Project: a platform for the conservation of endangered lorises

The LFP, an award-winning conservation project [S4a] directed by Nekaris, under the auspices of Oxford Brookes University, is dedicated to the study of the ecology of slow and slender lorises and contributes to the conservation and ecology of loris species throughout their ranges [S4b]. As stated by The Zoo Review: “ One organisation which is very active in the field, helping to protect slow lorises, is the Little Fireface Project. Many zoos that work with slow lorises have stepped up to support this organisation in its goals to save slow lorises” [S4c]. The zoos do this not only through funding the project, but by creating posters and outreach materials; co-writing the handbook for care of lorises in European Association of Zoos and Aquaria facilities; providing veterinary advice to the LFP field team; providing gum for rescued lorises; providing microchips for rescued and wild lorises; and organising keeper exchanges whereby zoo staff get to see lorises in the wild. In return, Nekaris and colleagues have worked with zoos to validate scientific equipment such as accelerometers; developed a pen pal programme between UK and Indonesian children for which they received a BIAZA Bronze Award; and attended keeper workshops and provided advice on housing of captive lorises. These achievements are largely due to the collaborative approach of the LFP, which has led to the development of a worldwide network of zoos and rescue centres that work together to create effective protocols to ensure the welfare of captive and wild slow lorises. Due to her internationally-recognised expertise, Nekaris is writing six out of 18 chapters of the protocols [S4b].

Improvement of the welfare of slow lorises in captivity

The LFP’s work to improve understanding of the behavioural ecology, feeding and captive breeding of slow lorises has improved their welfare and aided their reproduction in captivity in several zoos. According to feedback from the Curator of Conservation of the Cleveland Metroparks Zoo (USA), a collaborator and donor to the LFP: “ information such as including wild diets and behaviour were almost completely unknown before Nekaris’ work[S5a]. The Director of NaturZoo Rheine Germany has stated: “ We also value the results of Prof. Nekaris and her department’s studies on feeding ecology, habitat use and social organization having led to considerably improved management and propagation of slow lorises in zoological gardens” [S5b]. Other institutions that partner with the LFP, including the European Association of Zoos and Aquaria Prosimian (EAZA) Taxon Advisory Group [S5c], Shaldon Wildlife Trust (UK) [S5d], and Gauhati University (India) [S5e] have also attested that the work of Nekaris and the LFP, have guided the development of their protocols for maintaining slow lorises in captivity and shaped their campaigns to make the general public aware of the plight of these animals.

Improved rehabilitation, reintroduction and translocation procedures

The work of Nekaris and the LFP, on the rehabilitation and translocation of endangered lorises, has directly influenced the efforts of rescue centres throughout South and Southeast Asia, improving survival rates in captivity and developing effective protocols for lorises to be released to the wild. The Director of the Indonesian foundation Yayasan Peduli Kelestarian Satwa Liar (Wildlife Preservation Foundation), a project partner of LFP, affirmed that “Prof. Nekaris’ research on the feeding ecology, social organisation, habitat use, and behaviour of slow and slender lorises has directly influenced our management of these animals in our rescue and rehabilitation centre. Her work has significantly helped improve the welfare of the slow lorises and also speed up their rehabilitation process [S6]. With the limited capacities of rescue centres and the unsuitability of most confiscated lorises for reintroduction, rescue centres face difficult decisions about euthanasia. However, Nekaris has advocated for compassionate conservation, which balance the need for conservation with the demands of animal welfare. The Yayasan Peduli Kelestarian Satwa Liar Foundation has stated that “Compassionate conservation, rehabilitation and translocation of Indonesian slow lorises (Moore, Wihermanto & Nekaris, 2014) has been one of the essential study materials and guidelines for us when establishing the rescue program” [S7]. It is important to note that, previously, slow lorises were often so little known in rescue centres that they would typically die within weeks. Through training sessions in nine Asian countries (including Indonesia 2013, Japan 2017, Vietnam 2018 and with Love Wildlife Foundation in Thailand in 2019,) and more than 700 attendees in total, Nekaris has enabled many rescue centres to identify, for the first time, the animals entering their care, resulting in improved outcomes.

Increasing awareness through field projects, education and social media outreach

Nekaris’ understanding of the cultural drivers underpinning the loris trade in South and Southeast Asia has allowed her to develop diverse education programmes that are implemented through the LFP. The programmes educate and inform school children, teachers and the general public about the plight of lorises. In addition, conservation activities, such as the installation of water-pipe bridges in the Cipangati region in Java, benefit not only the lorises, through increasing in their home ranges and landscape accessibility, but also provide benefits to local communities (water irrigation), helping to improve local farmers’ attitudes towards wildlife. In 2019, Nekaris and colleagues helped farmers to certify their coffee as Wildlife Friendly by setting a requirement for a total hunting ban in the region. After the ban in 2019, Nekaris’ team, which had found traps almost weekly, has not detected a single trap [S8]. Since 2013, the LFP has run several local education programmes, including the Nature Club (Klub Alam) and the Slow Loris Forest Protector [S4b]. Each week, approximately 60 local students aged 3-17 come to Klub Alam to learn about their local ecology. Through the Slow Loris Forest Protector programme, an interactive approach that combines creativity and science to educate children on the conservation of habitats, wild flora and fauna, the LFP has reached more than 1,800 children aged 11-13 across Western Indonesia [S4b]. At the heart of this programme is a children’s book written by Nekaris, Slow Loris Forest Protector, that has now been translated into eight languages, including Indonesian, Vietnamese, Urdu, Spanish, French, Japanese, Greek and German, with at least 8500 copies distributed [S4b]. The educational campaigns of the LFP are supported by diverse teachers’ packs developed by Nekaris and her team, including Building Bridges for Slow Loris Conservation taught to 100 children in Java and shared online [S4b]. The LFP also implements other outreach activities such as the Slow Loris Outreach Week (S.L.O.W.), which has run every year since 2013. This consists of a worldwide week of activities to increase awareness of loris conservation and the impact of the trade on the species [S9]. Activities include the launching of short films and animations; partner zoos doing various activities and each year an education pack has been developed that is shared with the project partners (more than 50 zoos, rescue centres, other conservation groups). The National Geographic Society has endorsed the Outreach Week and stated: “Professor Anna Nekaris and team once again lead us overactive humans to S.L.O.W. down for Slow Loris Outreach Week. The third annual S.L.O.W. has been drawing attention to the struggles of this small and distant relative of ours via the Facebook page of the Little Fireface Project, encouraging people to update their background image with a poster about slow lorises to help spread the word[S10]. Nekaris’ YouTube study (R2) was used as the basis for International Animal Rescue’s ‘Tickling is Torture’ campaign ( https://www.ticklingistorture.org) as well as the Kukang Rescue Programme’s ‘I am not a toy’ campaign ( https://www.kukang.org/en/i-am-not-your-toy).The LFP also engages with the local and international community through various social media platforms to increase awareness of slow lorises. Its Twitter account (>4,600 tweets and 1,443 followers), Facebook page (>12,000 followers) where publications have reached a milestone of 8,000 likes and YouTube channel (531 subscriptions and 205,000 views) with a post that had more than 90,000 views, are key tools for increasing awareness about the plight of slow lorises [S4b].

5. Sources to corroborate the impact

Impact on wildlife trade legislation in Japan

S1. The Japan Times, Slow lorises at high risk of illegal trade in Japan, report finds ( 4th February 2016)

S2. Letter attesting Nekaris’ role in changes to Japan’s legislation from Japan Wildlife Conservation Society

S3. Traffic (Wildlife Trade Specialists), Japan tightens wildlife trade regulations ( 9th June 2017)

The Little Fireface Project

S4a. Born Free website; Professor Anna Nekaris of Oxford Brookes University and the Little Fireface Project was awarded the McKenna-Travers Award for Compassionate Conservation in 2013 https://www.bornfree.org.uk/mta

S4b. LFP project website, http://www.nocturama.org/en/welcome-little-fireface-project/

S4c. The Zoo Review, Little Fireface Project: The Un-Primates in Our Family Tree ( 7th April 2019)

Improvements in the diet and management of slow loris in zoos and rescue centres

5a. Testimonial from Cleveland Metropark Zoo, US

5b. Testimonial from NaturZoo Rheine, Germany

5c. Testimonial from Chair of EAZA Prosimian Taxon Advisory Group

5d. Testimonial from Shaldon Wildlife Organisation, UK

5e. Testimonial from B.H College, Assam, India

Improving breeding in rescue centres

S6. Testimonial from Love Wildlife Foundation, Thailand

Improving rehabilitation, reintroduction and relocation

S7. Testimonial from Yayasan Peduli Kelestarian Satwa Liar PASAL Foundation, Indonesia

S8. Article in The Guardian (UK): Fleming, A. Bridge over troubled forests: how Java’s slow lorises are creeping back (13 October 2020), available here

Slow Loris Outreach Week

S9. LFP project website, SLOW 2020 – Slow Loris Outreach Week( 19-25th October 2020)

S10. National Geographic, Slow Loris Outreach Week Is Here (Didn’t You Know?) ( 13th September 2014)

Submitting institution
Oxford Brookes University
Unit of assessment
5 - Biological Sciences
Summary impact type
Technological
Is this case study continued from a case study submitted in 2014?
Yes

1. Summary of the impact

Oxford Expression Technologies Ltd (OET) is a spin-out company of Oxford Brookes University (OBU) and the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) that exploits Intellectual Property in the area of gene expression using novel insect virus vectors. Initially time-consuming and requiring a high level of user skill, OET’s flashBACTM technology has enabled the production of recombinant proteins in a simplified, one-step process. OET sells kits, services and licences to pharmaceutical, biotechnological, diagnostic and vaccine companies in all continents as well as world-leading academic institutions, enabling them to increase the yields and quality of recombinant proteins, accelerating product development. This has resulted in diagnostic products reaching market for pig and poultry viral diseases, and viral vaccines entering clinical trials, including for [text removed for publication] and Covid-19. OET reinvests net profit and provides employment in collaborative research and development towards novel products, gene therapy and vaccines.

2. Underpinning research

Baculoviruses infect a wide range of insects and other invertebrates, but their inability to replicate in human cells makes them a very safe tool for biomedical researchers. OBU’s research (led by King) has played an important role in establishing the baculovirus as a workhorse for the development of new biologics and led to the creation of a successful spin-out company: OET.

The production of recombinant proteins plays an increasingly important role in the development of medical therapeutics, diagnostics and vaccines. The insect-derived baculovirus system for gene expression has the advantage of being very safe to use and of producing complex proteins in a much shorter timescale than other systems. However, its widespread adoption was initially hindered because of technological limitations; making recombinant viruses was time-consuming and a high level of user skill was required.

King (OBU) and Possee (NERC’s Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, CEH) have studied the basic biology and replication of baculoviruses since 1995. Their work led to the invention of a new, patented, baculovirus expression system that enabled the production of recombinant proteins in a simplified, one-step process. Since 2000, the research collaboration has been funded through a series of grants and PhD studentships (1) under the umbrella of a joint NERC-OBU exploitation agreement that led to the spin-out of OET (2007).

Since 2000, four patents have been approved worldwide (2), with OBU taking the lead role in exploitation and King and Possee named joint inventors. Research subsequent to patent filing has developed the technology further, enabling high-throughput production of baculovirus expression vectors (1a). These studies have led to the development of a new baculovirus expression system (commercially known as flashBACTM) that makes it possible to produce recombinant viruses in a one-step process, without the tedious and demanding selection step that separates recombinant from non-recombinant virus that is a feature of all other baculovirus expression systems.

Other collaborative research projects have continued to improve the original flashBACTM virus, making use of basic studies by King and Possee that identified the roles of various non-essential genes that encode viral enzymes important in virus replication: chitinase, cathepsin and P10 (1b, 1c). King and Possee have also made genetic modifications to the virus genome to delete chitinase and cathepsin ( flashBACGOLDTM), or all three genes ( flashBACULTRATM), and described the resulting improvements in recombinant protein production (3, 4). Deletion of chitinase significantly improves yields of secreted and membrane-targeted proteins (3, 4). Cathepsin is a viral protease and its deletion ensures that recombinant proteins are less likely to be degraded (4). P10 is a protein that forms an intricate cage-like structure in infected cells and facilitates nuclear disintegration (5, 6); its deletion improves cell viability and prolongs the period of recombinant protein production, leading to greater yields (3, 4). This research was exploited in the development of a flashBACmaxtransduction version with increased budded virus titres aimed at improving the efficacy of applications involving the transduction of human cells for gene therapy (1d, 5) (PDRA Graves moved to OET at the end of the grant).

Between 2013 and 2020, OET funded or co-funded five PhD students at OBU to further improve the baculovirus expression system, including a BBSRC iCASE studentship to develop novel approaches to vaccine production in insect cells. In 2018, OET was awarded a GBP2,000,000 Innovate UK/Small Business Research Initiative contract (Vaccines for Global Epidemics initiative) to develop a vaccine for Crimean Congo Haemorrhagic Fever (CCHF) Virus with Public Health England at Porton Down (PHE), University of Oxford Jenner Institute and OBU (King co-PI) as collaborators (1e). In May 2020, the remaining contract was repurposed to work on an insect cell-derived vaccine for Covid-19 (with Vaxine Pty, an Australian vaccine company), and in August 2020 Innovate UK provided a further GBP681,000 to progress the Covid-19 vaccine towards a Phase 1 clinical trial.

3. References to the research

1. Grant and studentship examples:

a) Automated high throughput systems for production of recombinant baculovirus expression vectors, BBSRC, 2003-2006, GBP230,000 awarded jointly to Brookes and CEH, Grant Ref: 332/B19427

b) Defining the genetic and environmental parameters affecting virus transmission between insect larvae, PI King, NERC Research Grant, 01/07/2002 to 30/06/2005, GBP255,801, Grant Ref: NER/A/S/2001/01069

c) The role of p10 in baculovirus morphogenesis and cellular pathogenesis, PI King, BBSRC Research Committee Studentship, 31/10/2002 to 31/10/2005, GBP27,000, Grant Ref: 02/B1/C/08354

d) Pretransplant gene therapy of pancreatic islet tissue; towards a therapy for Diabetes type 1 in Mexico. PI Possee, co-PI King, PDRA Graves, Innovate UK Newton (Mexico), 2016-2018, awarded jointly to OET (GBP180,000) and Brookes (GBP91,000), Grant Ref: 102731

e) Development of an economically viable vaccine for CCHF virus, co-PI King, Innovate UK/SBRI awarded to Possee (PI), OET Ltd 2018 (GBP2,000,000); May 2020 repurposed to develop a vaccine for Covid-19, Grant Ref: 972237

f) COVID-19: a rapidly scalable SARS-CoV-2 vaccine platform based on recombinant spike protein manufactured in insect cells using flashBAC to maximise yield and quality, co-PI King; Innovate UK awarded to Possee (PI), OET Ltd 2020 (GBP681,000), Grant Ref: 73370

2. Patents:

a) US Patents

i) US 7413732, https://patents.google.com/patent/US7413732B1/en

ii) US 8252278, https://patents.google.com/patent/US8252278B2/en?oq=US+8252278

b) European Patent; EP 1144666 B1, https://patents.google.com/patent/EP1144666B1/en?oq=+EP+1144666+B1

c) Australian Patent; AU 782205 B2, https://patents.google.com/patent/AU782205B2/en?oq=AU+782205+B2+

3. Possee, R. D., Hitchman, R. B., Richards, K. S., Mann, S. G., Siaterli, E., Nixon, C. P., Irving, C. H., Assenberg, R., Alderton, D., Owens, R. J. & King, L. A. (2008). Generation of baculovirus vectors for the high throughput production of proteins in insect cells. Biotechnology and Bioengineering, 101(6), 1115-1122. DOI: 10.1002/bit.22002

4. Hitchman, R. B., Possee, R. D., Siarterli, E., Richards, K. S., Clayton, A. J., Bird, L. E., Owens, R. J., Carpentier, D. C., King, F. L., Danquah, J. O., Spink, K. G. & King, L. A. (2010). Improved expression of secreted and membrane-targeted proteins in insect cells. Biotechnology and Applied Biochemistry, 56, 85-93. DOI: 10.1042/BA20090130

5. Graves, L. P., Aksular, M., Alakeely, R. A., Ruiz Bucks, D., Chambers, A. C., Murguia-Meca, F., Plata-Munoz, J. J., Hughes, S., Johnson, P. R. V., Possee, R. D. & King, L. A. (2018). Improved baculovirus vectors for transduction and gene expression in human pancreatic islet cells. Viruses 20, 10(10), 574. DOI: 10.3390/v10100574

6. Graves, L. P., Hughes, L., Irons, S. L., Possee, R. D. & King, L. A. (2019). In cultured cells the baculovirus P10 protein forms two independent intracellular structures that play separate roles in occlusion body maturation and their release by nuclear disintegration. PLoS Pathogens DOI: 10.1371/journal.ppat.1007827

4. Details of the impact

Pathway to impact

In 2007, with support from OBU’s Research & Business Development Office and investment of approximately GBP375,000, OET was founded to exploit the new baculovirus technology developed by King and Possee through marketing a range of kits, and by providing specialist services to commercial and academic users worldwide (S1). The patents granted to OBU and NERC’s CEH were licenced to the new company in return for shares and a royalty income stream. Since 2007, OET’s ethos has been to invest in research & development (R&D) to ensure its platform technologies remain competitive and at the forefront of new expression vector development, through in-house and collaborative R&D with a range of UK and international commercial, and academic, partners (S1). Since 2013, OET has launched four improved versions of its core flashBACTM expression platform, including one that increases transduction of mammalian cells to enhance gene therapy applications, and has sub-licensed the core technology for use in both veterinary and clinical applications in biotech, diagnostic and vaccine companies including [text removed for publication]. Since 2015, OET has also been successful in gaining GBP2,421,953 Innovate UK contracts and grants and co-invested c.GBP750,000 own funds to enable it to capitalise on its own innovative platform technologies to develop diagnostics and vaccines for emerging viral diseases in a strategic partnership with PHE Porton Down and others. Between 2014 and 2020, OET has more than doubled its scientific staff from 7 to 16 with 50% at PhD level (S2), and increased annual turnover 4.5-fold to [text removed for publication] and profit by six-fold (S3), much of which has been reinvested in R&D and growing the company. Today OET is acknowledged as a world-renowned centre of excellence for baculovirus expression technologies, benefitting global academic and commercial end users for research, diagnostic and vaccine purposes (S1, S4).

Impact August 2013 to present

The innovative technology ( flashBACTM) developed by King and Possee has resulted in a range of easy-to-use kits that enable users to make recombinant proteins in a rapid and convenient one-step process (S5). The benefits of the technology for end users relate partly to the simplification of the process, which enables a wide variety of academic and commercial laboratories to access the technology to make recombinant proteins without the need for a high level of virology-related skills. The simplified process is also quicker, thus saving several days’ time and resources in producing proteins at research scale through to bioreactors for commercial production. flashBACTM technology also has unique properties, which comprise: (1) its capacity for high-throughput production of multiple recombinant viruses, (2) improvements to the genetic backbone of the virus to generate higher yields of good-quality ‘difficult-to-express’ proteins and (3) avoidance of sequences that can lead to long-term genetic instability of the viral vector backbone.

While competitor baculovirus expression products exist (for example, Thermo Fisher’s BAC2BAC and BD Biosciences’ BACULOGOLD), the genetic backbones of these vectors have not been further developed since launching in the mid-1990s, and BAC2BAC retains bacterial sequences that can cause long-term genetic instability, often decreasing expression yields to almost zero over six or more passages of the virus and thus making it difficult to amplify virus for use at scale in bioreactors;. flashBACTM is the only baculovirus expression platform that has been genetically modified to improve the yield and quality of ‘difficult-to-express’ proteins (by deleting non-essential virus genes including chitinase, cathepsin and P10) and, at the same time, enabling high-throughput, simultaneous production of virus vectors in a simple one-step process. During the process of homologous recombination to insert foreign genes into the flashBACTM genome, bacterial artificial chromosome sequences (used to produce stocks of flashBACTM DNA) are deleted from the final vector sequences and hence recombinant flashBACTM vectors are genetically stable over the long-term, which ensures yields do not diminish during scale-up, for example, when providing a vaccine.

OET’s technology is now being used by multinational pharmaceutical (e.g. [text removed for publication]), biotech (e.g. [text removed for publication]), animal health companies (e.g. [text removed for publication]) and leading research institutions (e.g. PHE, the Francis Crick Institute and Universities of Oxford, Cambridge, Bristol, Manchester, Leicester, Reading, Gdansk, Aarhus, Wageningen, Harvard, Yale, Berlin, Tokyo, German Diabetes Centre, Animal & Plant Health Agency, APHA) worldwide to advance their drug discovery, biotherapeutic, diagnostic or vaccine development programmes. In addition, >100 companies and universities (many listed above) have also outsourced expression vector and protein production in insect cells to OET for ‘proteins to sell’ (e.g. [text removed for publication]) or incorporation into diagnostic assays or vaccines for veterinary (e.g. [text removed for publication]) and clinical purposes (e.g. [text removed for publication]); a number (>20) of larger academic research groups outsource construction of complex or challenging gene expression projects to OET’s experts, e.g. membrane proteins, virus-like particles and multiprotein complexes (e.g. Universities of [text removed for publication]).

Over the last few years, OET has completed increasing numbers of licence deals (>15) to enable companies to progress target vaccines or biotherapeutics through to clinical trials, or to commercialise products, (e.g. diagnostic assays) prepared using OET’s technology. For example, under a sub-licence agreement, OET produces many different proteins for [text removed for publication] for incorporation into its veterinary diagnostic assays for major avian (e.g. [text removed for publication]) and porcine (e.g. [[text removed for publication]) infectious diseases. In 2018, OET sub-licenced flashBACTM to [text removed for publication] for [text removed for publication] vaccine targets, two of which have successfully completed Phase 1 and 2 clinical trials for [text removed for publication]. In November 2020, [text removed for publication] vaccine for SARS-CoV-2 (the virus responsible for the Covid-19 global pandemic) (S6). The [text removed for publication] (S7). In August 2020, the UK Government [text removed for publication] (S8), and more recently [text removed for publication] (S9). In May 2020, OET agreed terms to licence its technology to Vaxine Pty, Australia for a vaccine for Covid-19, and in August 2020 Innovate UK provided GBP681,000 funding to OET to help Vaxine progress to a Phase 1 clinical trial.

The first commercial sales of flashBAC kits began in 2008 and the new technology has been widely adopted by the biotechnology sector (S4). Clients are both commercial and academic from across the globe, including all continents, either directly from OET’s Oxford base or through a number of international distributors (e.g. BioNovus for Australia, Cell Concepts for Germany, MirusBio for the US, Cosmo for Japan and Dakewe for Hong Kong and China) (S10), with non-UK kit sales comprising 80%. Approximately 43% of OET’s sales income ([text removed for publication]; 27% turnover, S3) over the assessment period derives from kit & product sales and, of this, approximately 40% through distributors and 60% direct sales. To access the American markets, the technology was licenced under Original Equipment Manufacturer agreements to [text removed for publication] and continues to be sold under the brand name [text removed for publication].

The flashBACTM technology is also used in-house by OET to produce recombinant proteins for customers unable to make them in their own laboratories and this accounts for approximately 43% [text removed for publication] of sales income (27% turnover). OET has thus established itself in the rapidly expanding market for ‘off-the-shelf’ research services that enable companies to avoid setting up their own dedicated facilities, enable them to outsource when in-house facilities are at capacity, or use OET’s expertise for complex or challenging projects. Since August 2014, OET has worked with >100 companies including [text removed for publication] plus government laboratories such as [text removed for publication] and many UK and global universities. We have enabled these companies and institutions to advance their drug discovery, diagnostic kit and/or vaccine development programmes by producing proteins more quickly and efficiently, and to increased yields and quality more than was possible previously. Companies utilizing OET technology are based in Europe, North and South America, South East Asia, Australia, the Middle East and China, as well as in the UK.

An increasing proportion of OET’s income comes from license deals to enable companies or organisations to use OET’s technology for commercial use including clinical trials for vaccine development (e.g. [text removed for publication]), Adeno-associated virus gene therapy vector production (e.g. [text removed for publication]) and multiple licences for commercial protein production (e.g. [text removed for publication]). A specific example of the licensed use of the technology has been in the development of vaccines for [text removed for publication], which have progressed to Phase 1, 2 and 3 clinical trials, respectively. Commercial protein production varies from simple preparation of proteins for sale to use of proteins in in vitro diagnostic assays (e.g. [text removed for publication]). Licence sales income accounted for 14% of OET’s sales income (8% of turnover; S4) in the designated period with individual licences ranging from [text removed for publication].

5. Sources to corroborate the impact

S1. OET website – www.oetltd.com

S2. OET staff organograms 2013 and 2020 to show increase in staff over the period

S3. OET finance statement to show income by kits, services, licence and R&D income and relative proportions over time per year 2013-2020 and in total over qualifying period

S4. Exemplar list of publications citing use of flashBAC to make proteins 2014-2020; Google Scholar = 359, 2014-2020

S5. List of baculovirus products in kit format; also https://oetltd.com/shop-baculovirus-expression/

S6. [text removed for publication] who licenced OET’s technology to make a vaccine to Covid-19

S7. [text removed for publication]

S8. [text removed for publication]

S9. [text removed for publication]

S10. Map to show distributors of flashBAC worldwide; also https://oetltd.com/about/distributors/

Submitting institution
Oxford Brookes University
Unit of assessment
5 - Biological Sciences
Summary impact type
Technological
Is this case study continued from a case study submitted in 2014?
No

1. Summary of the impact

Professor Groome at Oxford Brookes University (OBU) developed the Inhibin B monoclonal antibody 46A/F and an assay procedure that has contributed to significant improvement in the sensitivity and reproducibility of his first-generation Inhibin B enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). The improved assay, the Gen II Inhibin B ELISA, has had major clinical impact through the development of reliable reference ranges for clinical diagnosis of male and female fertility, and the diagnosis and monitoring of granulosa cell tumours of the ovary, improving the treatment and outcomes of patients worldwide. Royalty income was [text removed for publication] between August 2013 to July 2020, which is indicative of cumulative sales in excess of [text removed for publication] across the world.

2. Underpinning research

This impact case focuses on a second-generation Inhibin B assay developed by Professor Groome at OBU, which has lowered the detection limit, and improved the convenience and reliability, of the first-generation Inhibin B assay. Inhibin B is produced by the Sertoli cells in the testes and granulosa cells in the ovaries, which makes its concentration in body fluids a direct indicator of the functional status of testes and ovaries [R1]. Consequently, assaying Inhibin B levels has paved the way for improved male fertility testing, assessment of ovarian reserve/menopause onset and enhanced screening/monitoring programmes for those at risk of ovarian cancer [R1, R2, R3].

In the 1990s, Groome developed antibodies that recognise Inhibins, a group of hormones that regulate the reproductive system by acting on the pituitary gland and blocking the synthesis and secretion of follicle stimulating hormone (FSH). Groome then developed the first clinical assays for Inhibins using his antibodies. Inhibins are heterodimeric molecules containing an α subunit and either a βA (forming Inhibin A) or βB (forming Inhibin B) subunit. Activins contain two β subunits and can be homodimeric or heterodimeric: two βA subunits make Activin A, two βB subunits make Activin B and a βA subunit attached to a βB subunit makes Activin AB. Activin B is closely related to Inhibin B but has the opposite biological effect of enhancing FSH biosynthesis and secretion.

The first-generation Inhibin B assay developed by Groome was widely commercialised in the late 1990s through Oxford Bio-Innovation (OBI), an OBU spin-out company, acquired by Diagnostic Systems Laboratories (DSL) in 1998. DSL was acquired by Beckman Coulter in 2005. The OBI and DSL assays used monoclonal antibodies C5 and R1 developed at OBU [R1]. They comprised multiple steps, including sample oxidation to allow the C5 antibody to recognise its epitope, with the OBI assay including a sample boiling pretreatment step to remove assay interferences [R4, R5], and had sensitivities that were not quite adequate for routine use on some patient samples (such as those from menopausal women that typically contain low levels of Inhibin B) [R6]. Sensitivity could be increased by prolonging the time the antibodies reacted with the serum sample, but this was difficult in routine clinical use. Critically, the low and variable sensitivities of the assays impeded the establishment of reliable reference ranges, which are essential for accurate diagnosis and patient care.

Groome recognised the need to develop simpler, but more accurate and sensitive, assays for Inhibin B. He and his PhD student Helen Ludlow achieved this by raising a new antibody specific for the Inhibin/Activin B subunit peptide by immunising mice with Xenopus laevis Activins [R6]. The resulting 46A/F antibody does not require processing of the sample with heat or oxidising agents, and its sensitivity is threefold higher than that of the C5/R-based assays [R4]. Thus, 46A/F provides a simpler, more sensitive immunoassay for a wider range of sample types, including samples from patients with decreased ovarian reserve. Additionally, 46A/F, unlike C5, can pair with itself in two-site immunoassays, which has led to the first successful immunoassay for the Activin B heterodimer in clinical research [R5, R6]. OBU filed a patent for the new antibody and its applications in the USA, and this was granted in 2013 [R6]. The US patent was licensed exclusively to Beckman Coulter together with the assay for Inhibin B and the component antibodies 46A/F and R1 for commercial exploitation.

3. References to the research

R1. Evans, LW, Groome, NP (2001) Development of immunoassays for Inhibin, Activin and follistatin. In: Muttukrishna, S., Ledger, W. (Eds.), Inhibin, Activin and Follistatin in Human Reproductive Physiology. Imperial College Press, London, p. 11. ISBN: 9781860942051

R2. Lutchman Singh K, Muttukrishna S, Stein RC, McGarrigle HH, Patel A, Parikh B, Groome NP, Davies MC, Chatterjee R (2007) Predictors of ovarian reserve in young women with breast cancer. British Journal of Cancer. 96(12): 1808–1816. DOI: 10.1038/sj.bjc.6603814

R3. Young JM, Henderson S, Souza C, Ludlow H, Groome N, McNeilly (2012) Activin B is produced early in antral follicular development and suppresses thecal androgen production. Reproduction. 143:637-650. DOI: 10.1530/REP-11-0327

R4. Ludlow H, Muttukrishna S, Hyvönen M, Groome NP (2008) Development of a new antibody to the human Inhibin/Activin betaB subunit and its application to improved Inhibin B ELISAs. Journal of Immunological Methods. 329(1-2):102-11. DOI: 10.1016/j.jim.2007.09.013.

R5. Ludlow H, Phillips DJ, Myers M, McLachlan RI, Kretser DM, Allan CA, Andreson RA, Groome NP, Hyvönen M, Duncan WC (2009) A new ‘total’ Activin B enzyme‐linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA): development and validation for human samples. Clinical Endocrinology. 71:867-73. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2265.2009.03567.x

R6. Groome NP, Ludlow H. Antibody to Inhibin/Activin beta B subunit US patent number 8383351 Granted February 26th 2013. https://patents.google.com/patent/US8383351B2/en

4. Details of the impact

The work of Professor Groome has had both significant commercial and clinical impact. The Inhibin B assay has benefitted millions of women and men around the world affected by fertility problems or granulosa cell malignant ovarian tumours.

Impact on commerce

OBU licensed the 46A/F antibodies and test exclusively to Beckman Coulter, which launched an improved Inhibin B manual assay, the Gen II Inhibin B ELISA, in 2012 [S1]. Worldwide sales reported by Beckman Coulter, in more than 60 countries, totalled [text removed for publication] between August 2013 and July 2020, giving OBU an income of [text removed for publication] [S2].

Impacts on human healthEstablishing reference ranges for clinical assays

The increased detection range of the Gen II Inhibin B ELISA has led to the establishment of reliable and updated reference ranges for Inhibin B in plasma. The first-generation Inhibin B assay was of limited use in the assessment of testicular function due to a lack of reliable reference ranges. Although the majority of medical decisions are based on information provided by clinical tests, these by themselves are of little value unless they are supported by relevant information for their interpretation. With the Gen II Inhibin B ELISA, reliable reference ranges have been established for Inhibin B in male body fluids. These reference ranges have been key in improving the diagnosis of a number of male genital conditions, including disorders of spermatogenesis and testicular development [S3].

Male infertility

Infertility is estimated to affect 10-15% of couples. Approximately 40% of all infertility cases can be attributed entirely to male factors. Serum Inhibin B levels were rapidly established as an important, sensitive marker of male fertility. Analysis of serum Inhibin B reflects the relationship between Inhibin B, Sertoli cell function and spermatogenesis. Serum Inhibin B is a better marker of male fertility status than FSH because Inhibin B is produced by the Sertoli cells in the testes. Thus, serum Inhibin B has a positive correlation with sperm count and is used for the evaluation of male infertility as a non-invasive predictor of spermatogenesis. The Gen II Inhibin B ELISA is widely used by the National Health Service (NHS) in the UK, and health providers around the world, to assess male fertility, impacting positively on the well-being and fertility outcomes of millions of men and their families [S4]. The increased sensitivity and accuracy of the assay has led to its use as an indicator of the presence of sperm in testes in men with azoospermia. Azoospermia is defined as the complete absence of sperm in ejaculate and is responsible for 10-15% of all infertility in men. Men with azoospermia who test positive for testicular sperm can recover the sperm through testicular extraction procedures and use it for fertility purposes [S5].

Female fertility: ovarian reserve screening

The amount of Inhibin B measured in serum during the start of a new menstrual cycle is directly related to the number and health of small growing follicles. The Beckman Coulter Gen II Inhibin B ELISA is used by fertility clinics to assess ovarian reserve [S6, S7], which assesses the potential number of eggs a woman has in her ovaries. This information is critically important to establish adequate fertility treatments. The Beckman Coulter Gen II Inhibin ELISA is used as an adjunct to FSH and anti-Müllerian (AMH) hormone testing because the combined measurement of these hormones and Inhibin B can better predict ovarian response and pregnancy outcome than FSH or AMH alone [S6, S7]. Before the introduction and validation of these assays as a measure of ovarian reserve, the only evidential source of guidance for mature women interested in their reproductive futures, for whatever reason, was their age. The use of Inhibin B plus the other assays has significantly improved the clinical advice women receive about their fertility status and is key in enabling them to make life decisions pertaining to their fertility on solid scientific grounds.

Screening for ovarian cancer

Ovarian cancer remains the seventh most common cancer, and eighth most common cause of death from cancer, in women in the world. Although there has been significant improvement in the visualisation of ovarian tumours (e.g. transvaginal sonography), ovarian cancer remains a substantial challenge because of late diagnosis and high mortality rates. However, the discovery that Inhibin B expression is restricted to ovarian granulosa cells in women has led to Inhibin B levels being established as a useful serum marker of granulosa cell turnover. Today, testing for Inhibin B is key in the diagnosis of granulosa cell tumours and mucinous epithelial ovarian tumours [S8]. Ovarian cancer is classified into 3 types: epithelial (80%); germ cell tumours (10-15%); and stromal sex-cord tumours (5-10%), with granulosa cell tumours representing the majority of stromal sex-cord tumours. Inhibin B levels are increased by approximately 60-fold over the range of reference values in 89–100% of patients with granulosa cell tumours [S8]. Inhibin B is also a serum marker for mucinous epithelial tumours, with 55–60% having increased Inhibin B levels, and has a better performance in muscinous and granulosa ovarian cancer than the tumour marker CA125 [S8]. The major impact of Inhibin B testing on women’s treatment and outcomes is illustrated by the following comments from a patient with ovarian cancer: “ In Aug 2010 I received a letter from my consultant advising me that my Inhibin levels had risen from their usual bottom of the scale levels and I went to see him. 2 CT scans Sept and Dec 10 showed nothing but my Inhibin B had climbed to 344. I went into hospital for an exploratory laparoscopy in Jan 11, for the docs to discover a 7cm tumour in my abdomen and several small tumours in the pelvic gutter” [S9].

Development of a clinical assay for myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome

Professor Groome’s active pursuit of new international collaborations with scientists and clinicians has led to the discovery that the 46A/F antibody can be used as a biomarker for myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS) [S10]. ME/CFS affects around 0.4% of people worldwide and causes unexplained, persistent, and sometimes disabling, fatigue, with no definitive diagnostic tests or treatments available. However, recent clinical studies that have used the 46A/F antibody to monitor levels of Activin B in patients with ME/CFS have shown that levels of this protein are approximately 2-fold higher in patients with ME/CFS compared with controls. 46A/F is able to detect Activin B because this protein is made of two βB peptides, which are recognised by the 46A/F antibody. These studies offer, for the first time, hope of a reliable and accurate test to diagnose ME/CFS and monitor the effectiveness of treatment [S10].

5. Sources to corroborate the impact

S1. Beckman Coulter Gen II Inhibin B ELISA manual [ link]

S2. Confidential commercial information showing the income on Inhibin B, 2013–2020, Commercial and Knowledge Exchange Director, Research Business Development Office, Oxford Brookes University

S3. Examples of the use of Beckman Coulter Gen II Inhibin B ELISA to establish reliable reference ranges for plasma Inhibin B

  • Barbotin A-L, Ballot C, Sigala J, Ramdane N, Duhamel A, Marcelli F, Rigot JM, Dewailly D, Pigny P, Mitchell V (2015) The serum Inhibin B concentration and reference ranges in normozoospermic. European Journal of Endocrinology 172(6): 669-676. DOI: 10.1530/EJE-14-0932

  • Molinaro F, Cerchia E, Garzi A, Severi M, Angotti R, Petraglia, Messina M (2016) Serum levels of Inhibin B in adolescents after varicocelectomy: A long term follow up. Open Medicine 11(1):204-206. DOI: 10.1515/med-2016-0039

S4. Examples of clinics and pathology departments using Inhibin B tests for testicular function

  • Imperial College Healthcare, Test Directory [ link]

  • Royal United Hospitals Bath NHS [ link]

S5. Examples of clinical studies on the use of Beckman Coulter Gen II Inhibin B ELISA to monitor azoospermia

  • Alhalabi M (2016) Predictive value of serum Inhibin B levels as an indicator of the presence of testicular spermatozoa in non-obstructive azoospermia. Middle East Fertility Society Journal 21(4): 246-252. DOI: 10.1016/j.mefs.2016.05.001

  • Isaksson S, Eberhard J, Ståhl O, Cavallin-Ståhl E, Cohn-Cedermark G, Arver S, Lundberg Giwercman Y, Giwercman A (2014) Inhibin B concentration is predictive for long term azoospermia in men treated for testicular cancer. Andrology 2(2): 252-258. DOI: 10.1111/j.2047-2927.2014.00182.x

S6. Examples of articles from health organisations discussing use of Inhibin B assay to assess ovarian reserve in females

  • ‘The Role of Inhibin B in Fertility Treatments’, Nicole Galan, verywellhealth, 17 November 2019 [ link]

  • Inhibin B Test, Women & Infants [ link]

S7. Examples of routine NHS lab use of Beckman Coulter Gen II Inhibin B ELISA for assessment of ovarian reserve

  • Blood Test Information, Inhibin B, Royal United Hospitals Bath NHS [ link]

  • Inhibin B, Tests and investigations, Gloucestershire Hospitals NHS [ link]

S8. Examples of routine hospital lab use of Beckman Coulter Gen II Inhibin B ELISA in the UK and US for differentiating ovarian tumours with normal CA125 stromal or mucinous epithelial tumours

  • Test ID: INHB Inhibin B, Serum, Mayo Clinic Laboratories (a global reference laboratory that helps health care providers worldwide advance patient care and broaden access to specialised testing) [ link]

  • Test Directory, Inhibin B, ARUP Laboratories [ link]

  • Inhibin (B), Clinical Use: Testing for inhibin can be used as an aid in the diagnosis of granulosa cell tumours and mucinous epithelial ovarian tumours. It can also be used as an aid in assessing infertility issues. South Tees Hospitals NHS [ link]

S9. Compelling example of a patient describing how Inhibin B assays helped to identify and monitor her cancer, Cancer Research UK, Forum post ‘Ovarian granulosa cell tumour’ [ link]

S10. Activin B, a new tool to diagnose ME/CFS

  • ‘Could we finally have a definitive biomarker for ME/CFS?’, ME Research UK, 9 June 2017 [ News]
Showing impact case studies 1 to 4 of 4

Filter by higher education institution

UK regions
Select one or more of the following higher education institutions and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.
No higher education institutions found.
Institutions

Filter by unit of assessment

Main panels
Select one or more of the following units of assessment and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.
No unit of assessments found.
Units of assessment

Filter by continued case study

Select one or more of the following states and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.

Filter by summary impact type

Select one or more of the following summary impact types and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.

Filter by impact UK location

UK Countries
Select one or more of the following UK locations and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.
No UK locations found.
Impact UK locations

Filter by impact global location

Continents
Select one or more of the following global locations and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.
No global locations found.
Impact global locations

Filter by underpinning research subject

Subject areas
Select one or more of the following underpinning research subjects and then click Apply selected filters when you have finished.
No subjects found.
Underpinning research subjects